Rating
There Were Times When I Wished You Were Dead Average 3.2 / 5 out of 0.9K
Rank
N/A, it has 48.4K monthly views
Alternative
네가 죽기를 바랄 때가 있었다
Author(s)
Type
Updating
Summary
There Were Times When I Wished You Were Dead
Read New Manhwa There Were Times When I Wished You Were Dead / 네가 죽기를 바랄 때가 있었다
The Emperor of Croisen hated Empress Yvonne. Enough that he’d wish for her to disappear three times a day.
I don’t like the face of someone who looks just like the Duke of Delois, my enemy, but no matter how much I insulted her, her indifferent and aloof character stayed the same, which made me feel even more terrible.
I didn’t care whether or not she disappears or dies. I was fine with anything as long as I didn’t see her face.
The wish came true.
When he no longer wished for it to happen.
- 네가 죽기를 바랄 때가 있었다
Search for series of same genre(s)
Welcome to S2manga site, you can read and enjoy all kinds of Manga trending such as Drama, Manhua, Manhwa, Fantasy, v.vv…, for free here. All of the manga new will be update with high standards every 24 hours. If you are a Comics book (Manga Hot ), S2manga is your best choice, don’t hesitate, just read and feel !
Show more
-
Chapter 31
- Chapter 30 January 17, 2022
- Chapter 29 January 15, 2022
- Chapter 28 January 9, 2022
- Chapter 27 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 25 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 24 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 10 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 9 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 6 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 5 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 4 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 1 January 6, 2022
Show more
MANGA DISCUSSION
Leave a Reply
561 Comments
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
mycheeseysoup
i hate hate HATE the emperor
Blank
Trust me when I say you aint the only one
NieveS
PLease update!!
katsundae
I know it’s only chapter 1, but my blood is already boiling. Emperor’s such a horrible person, ugh
NieveS
not even lying i cried for her out of ALOT of anger and sadness
wintermadison
what the hell😃🔪
wintermadison
pls tell me he’s not the ml, I HATE HIM ALREADY
Kiyyqq
I’m begging you don’t let this be the ML PLEASE DONT PLEASE
Mikasa_Ackerman
Emperor – Trash
kwMWi_21
PLEASE do not let this TRASHY emperor be the ML!!!! UGH just thinking about him is making my blood boil!
MoonmistLuna
Chapter 2 please
alpas
GUYS THIS IS A SAD STORY AHHHHHHHHHHH
Famika
So…. When the empress will kill the bitch?
Kardeal
It’s only first chapter and I already want a divorce
clairederiver
folks I’m telling you, this story will be an emotional roller coaster. there’d be hella misunderstandings and you will know who’s the real devil behind all this
Sara
AH I can already see it, this is the ML.
Can someone spoil it for me please🤦🏻♀️ First chapter and my blood was boiling. I cant withstand years to find out who’s the villain 😩
Madia
Ohhh shittt trashta vibesss
hola
the emperor is worse than trashatas husband (i dont remember his name cuz y shud i remember useless people like him names)i would like to inoccently st….ab him 😇🔪
ZekiLee
“The wish came true.
When he no longer wished for it to happen.”
Ohhhh, that’s gonna be heartbreaking for him then. He deserves it, he already chose his route.
Kein
I legit hate this bastard
Lover_of_thoughts
I’m waiting…
I’m waiting for when the empress will bring in a concubine~
I’m like soooooo hoping that’ll happen and then she gets pregnant and the story has gone crazyyyy like meeeeeeeh🤪🤪
So u r lukas 2.0
I’m in empress support😚
YoThotPlsBackTFOff
my thot sense is reacting to that kiana black haired disgusting bish
O w O
can’t you see your wife, the empress. is more prettier???????!!!! WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU!!!
Le Tired
I already read the mtl’d novel and he mentally tortures her with public humiliation, denigrates her at every chance he gets, and shoots spiteful words in her face in an effort to break through her “calm mask” b/c he wants to see her lose her composure.
—————————————————————————————–
SPOILERS:
Emperor was looking for a girl that helped him escape his kidnappers when they were children and it turned out to be her. She couldn’t say / write / etc. who she was b/c her father hired a magician to place a curse on her to prevent her from leaking her identity as his illegitimate daughter who replaced his real, dead daughter. He only found out who she was after he had done and said all these terrible, inhuman things to her and he wanted to die hahaha. But she ends up forgiving him after a brief separation and he becomes the perfect husband….they live happily ever after…..Idk why she couldn’t have been w/ new love interest like Remarried Empress or I Don’t Love You Anymore
JustUser
The emperor is such a womanizer, b*tch, and other f*ucking bad things I shouldn’t say for the sake of other people. Emperor die and go to hell hahah
Akio
^Thank you for the spoilers but honestly u are right, This should’ve had something like remarried Empress
Miss1sara
Wow , already a new trash’s name in my list.
GODESS🔪OF 🔪ASSASINATION
What FUCK
ThisIsMahLife
please update soon i love the story authur i need another chapter please🥺🥺
Starfire624
I think he is just trying to get her jellies
Riviera
I don’t know why but I am having a blood rush in my veins I am just really pissed right now
Lol
it remind me of remarriaged empress such .basterds the bothe emperors are even if they doing this out to get atention still i want them both dead i hope our female lead end up divorcing and be with nice man
Lol
So i read someone spoiler emeror is going to humliate and deisrespect her a lot and yet she still will be forgive her and live with him happily its just like abanden empress
F**k that im not going to waste my time reading such stupid manhwa
I drop this
ItsYaNnA
There’s no hier ?? Well that’s because the emperor is a shit ✨
._.lttlrbbt
what the f I hate the emperor so mucccchhhh atghsuuahaiajaia
miss panda
what a asshole
[email protected]
If the emperor is the ML he better have one hell of a redemption arc that piece of trash
Crunchy
Ugh im about to read the novel version…. heartache is on the way😭😭 ugh hate cheaters
Chiyuki
Ah no way, don’t let this trash be the ml oh gosh i won’t accept him, i– aaaaaaaaa
Ali
This looks like abandoned empress 2.0
Moon
Is it trashta 2.0….? ( the remarried empress)
Banana pie
Lol i just read its novel today and i must say lets all prepared some tissue
CivilsAan
Please Update ASAP
Thank You 🙂
Hellarthemis10
Ohmy.grr my anxiety 😤
Elizabeth
I actually read the novel and I can say that the emperor is a really big shit. WE WILL LOVE THE EMPRESS
Z_ai
I would love to kill the emperor
Carbonara
ITS GOODDD READ THE NOVEL ITS GOOD
nozomiaoi13
trash
nozomiaoi13
@Le Tired, what forgiving him? just leave that trash alone :<
hunnydeedy
Next.. next.. I wish there is any updated chapter.. please…. 🥺🥺🥺
OneWingAngel
I felt like I read this story before… if i’m not mistaken the emperor is the ml.. it was a good story nevertheless… though i kinda really hate the emperor at first. 😅 But still i’m not really sure if this is it.
kMarlo
I hope he’s not the male lead. Please don’t be the male lead!
Lya K
hah! gives me the vibes of “Remarried Empress”… but the art is beautiful!
lia_x
potakte na yan, the only way this story would be saved in my eyes is if the citizens of the empire aren’t idiots and support the empress more than the emperor, ngl i feel like that’s what’s up but i don’t trust it just yet
Froggy_frog
Join this server if you love Manhwa ❤️
Link: https://discord.gg/rbWxS2zzwn
A manhwa server
•Manhwa/Manga recommendations
•SFW
•Active with over 4k members
•Fun Bots
•They rarely tag everyone
•Giveaways
•Friendly staff and members
July 5, 2021 at
lin zei
it has similarity to the remarried empress,….coincidence?
borbolune
uh oh i was reading the novel and this is really great… i’m excited
moonjavenue
Worst version of sovieshit huh
westieee
what the hell is wrong the emperror? wth
westieee
just divorce that wutnut emperror wth
vee
why the emperor did that!!! Its making me soooo angryyy!
Pinkery
The audacity-
amynamy
i hate when that kind of a**** become all of a sudden the perfect ML, after putting the FL through so much misery. People, let’s normalize leaving that kind of trash !!!!
Rin
BRUH- How dare you do that to her😀🔪🔪
Lotusrina
Ohhh another trashy emperor i see😀 God please don’t let him be the male lead
Soteria
I already read the manga and I know why the Emperor is doing this but dayum does this scene make me want to fetch my meatcleaver. （╯°□°）╯︵(\ .o.)\
Raven A.W ●~●
Finished already come on it was getting intressting😑😑😑😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Ceniza
I have read this… I know his reasons for doing this however, I cannot forgive him until he crawls into mud and suffers more than her….
Kuronight
I have a horrible feeling this would not turn out like “Remarried Empress” because he looked to see her reaction so i hope and pray that if Empress is FL she would not end up with that fucker but i doubt we would see similar plot with divorce
[email protected]
Please update ASAP and release as many chapters as possible this is so good!!!
maru
this is giving me the abandoned empress vibes :_:
maru
btw dont they look similar? I mean the guy and the “queen”. I thought they were siblings for a sec
Snazzy 💅💅
Oh my goodness I want to fucking throw his nasty ass down a well and set it on fire 🔥😤
remmii
Emperor, get in the bin right now
error
the emperor and that girl kiana or whatever i forgot look like siblings
Ametrine
MORE PLEASE MORE I need to see this dick die a painful and slow death!!!! Such a douche!!! How dare he do something so disrespectful – have they no shame??? In front of all those people?? Wow…….The empress seems too calm maybe she’s scheming revenge….I want to see his downfall along with the bitch!! Both of them have no shame….
Haruhi
Seems like remarried empress…….
wow
wow trash emperor lol
Divibe
what if there’s a reason why the emperor acts like a jerk? What if the empress is actually the bad one here? It’s only chapter 1, there’s still a lot we don’t know about
Anrann
I dont care if his the ml but i would like the fl to end up with a second ml, because that ml just has a messed up attitude and brain to be the ml here.
Noona
Oh my 😻is that trashta
Le Tired
I wrote spoilers at the top w/o including the fact that I found this unreadable not b/c of the story, but how it emotionally affected me; I can’t fathom experiencing what MC went though, emperor was really awful. She was upset about it & at many points in the story she tried to tell him who she was but couldn’t b/c of the curse. He was too dumb to catch the BIGGEST HINTS she threw out.
*(Idk why I can’t reply to my own comment) A bit more SPOILERS below:
MC was protecting emperor from her scheming father while living w/ a level of mental anguish thanks to the emperor (the irony) that broke her down and led her to commiting self harm. Emperor knew about it and felt guilty but not enough to stop crushing her self esteem for his own satisfaction. I had to take a break many times then gave up and read the spoilers so I could skip middle part for my sanity; I ended up reading first third of story & last third where emperor found out her identity and tried to repent by taking his own life. MC was like wtf if you really want to punish yourself live knowing what you did to me instead of weaseling your way out of this. Also, i’m too tired to hate you but I def don’t want to see your face anymore. He is then sad and is unable to do anything but work b/c he has nightmares everyday about how he treated her lol.
Queen Kiana is not a Trashta, she is cool and tried to create a positive image for MC to emperor and told him to get to know her before making his own conclusions. She was indirectly helping her but couldn’t do much b/c SPOILER: she had a mission to do while being a fake queen.
I_Love_ur_manga
Please more update ♥︎
Bxlla
giving off very much Remarried Empress vibes
Just a 🥔
Asshole 😒.umm what is dis sovieshit smell 🧘🏻♀️🧘🏻♀️
Blanc_the_cat
that son of a b*tch! another Sovieshit and Trashta!!
Alessia
What I concluded ;
1> The empress has her circumstances and hence is cold towards the emperor 2> He doesn’t see it yet(the circumstances of why she acts like the way she does) and loves her
3> She is showing no signs of affection and while depressed and drunk when confronted by the other girl
4> He thought that if he has another girl she would react and hence sleeps with her .
5> The empress isn’t showing but I think she likes the emperor and they both have there own misunderstandings .
6> And from the title I can say that The ML is A YANDERE .
Hubbahubba
Damn…..another “even though i brought another hoe, treat you like trash, but actually in my pov i want your attention and love even though i myself dont do shit for you” manwhore 🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️🤦♀️
kanao_tsyuri
what a scumbag this reminds me of remarried empress
Aira
As a person, I would wait for the chapters to read before I judge any characters in this story. I dont wanna say trash or biatch to them. So I will wait. 🤫
Myra
The fucking bastard with bitch
I hate the emperror and Kiana Roden (bitch)
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
Okay so the logic is like, the ML can bring whoever woman he want and the Empress I mean FL is just going to watch is peacefully and do whatever they please. Seriously…
Alice
More pwease 🥺
wtf
OOH PLS UPDATE THIS LOOKS SO GOOD!!!
Le Tired
@Alessia There’s not much romance for most of the novel, it mostly focuses on trauma & PTSD
Because of emperor’s prejudice towards empress and not knowing her real identity, he doesn’t actually love her yet. He becomes fond of her and starts to like her after getting to know her but didn’t want to like her b/c he’s hung up on the girl from his childhood.
Emperor didn’t bring in new queen to make empress jealous, (SPOILERS) she was brought in b/c she’s the Marquis’s daughter and the marquis family is a loyal vassal of the emperor who’s trying to help him bring down empress’s awful father. The second reason was to embarrass her publicly in front of their vassals by emphasizing that it was a sham marriage forced by empress’s dad, the duke, in a bid to produce a successor to obtain more power. He wasn’t trying to make her jealous, he was angry for what her dad did (attempted & successful assassination of royal family) but he took it out on the empress….
The empress didn’t like the emperor in the beginning b/c the long term mental abuse he inflicted on her made her emotionally numb and the duke’s abuse made her feel like being emotional was a luxury. She starts to like him after they spend time together but there was an event that made him think she was colluding w/ the duke to kill him (she wasn’t, he was paranoid, there was no proof) and she realized no matter what she did it wouldn’t change how he viewed her, so she gave up on him.
Also, it’s impossible to hate Queen Kiana, she is great and lowkey tried to help fix their broken marriage. She felt really bad that the empress looked like a dead woman walking
BakemonoRis
Well the Author did a good job on such a bad first impression of that asshole
Lasciel
I’m very curious to see how she’ll get back at him!
Alyawils19
I can’t wait for more!! This gives me The Remarried Empress vibes.
gucigucishalalala
This is the first time I agreed that the possible ml is such a trash. I feel like killing him.
Alyawils19
I feel bad about the empress but I can’t blame the emperor why he’s treating the empress that way. Because of her father the duke , he killed half of the emperor’s family and the emperor was kidnapped and almost killed when he was young and he believed that the duke was behind all of that. The duke wants the power of emperor and it’s a forced marriage . So I kinda understand him that he don’t trust the empress and he hates her to death. The relationship between the emperor and the queen it based on contract ……. Okay I will stop now.
I wish s2 will update more!!! I wanna see the emperor’s reaction when he found out the truth about the empress…
Nnsyrahh
Please don’t be a promo😭🙏🏻
CeeBee
Guys I think he’s the ML 🥲
Imwaitingforthetruckkun
Soviesh*t 2.0
[email protected]
Please please please update soon and as many chapters as possible
Nina
Guys.. he is the one who wished she is dead..
shxxxxbi1027
Guys I read the novel. Its soooo good
Littleira
I hope the emperor is not the ML, you stupid jerk!!
ari
I HOPE THIS ISNT A PROMO 😭
Divibe
There’s still no update…is it perhaps a promo?
Mikaela
WHY WOULD HE ABANDONED SUCH BEAUTY OVER A TRASH LIKE THAT BLACK HAIRED SLT?!!!!! IS HE INSANEEEEEEEE?!!!!! OR HE’S JUST STUPID?😭😭😭😭✋
larsheen
THEN WHEN THE 2ND MALED LEAD COMES THAT BITCH IS GONNA BE JEALOUS 😭😭😭😭😭
larsheen
This emperor remind me of SOVIESHIT
Mira~
I kinda think he was making the empress jealous. But damn that emperor is a FOKEHN AZHOL!(눈‸눈)
Anisa
I liked his story very much, I’m waiting for the story to continue soon
Good luck👍🏼
ari
PLS DONT BE A PROMO IV BEEN WAITING FOR THISSS
Manwha obsessed ✅
I hate the emperor so much
Kuronight
Gonna drop it i really cant do it another round where i would see trash Emperor like in Remarried and i could only hold on because i did read the Novel of remarried so knowing that an FL will get away from such an Asshole thats why i could hang on xD
Dy
Dear emperor, “There Were Times When I Wished You Were Dead”… Yes, just like the title.
Alyawils19
Ha I been waiting for this finally!
remmii
I hope that man eats dirt
Venti simp
This son of a bitch. This asshole. This- AGGHHHHHANCAGJSGJAGJSGJA THIS PEICE OF TRASH
Venti simp
Piece* fuck i can’t even spell. This is a first.
lilacsdemon
hm
Alaax
i thought it was a promo im glad its not
Inoka
No both parties are tormented by ……………..
Well if I say this it will be a spoiler……😑
Alyawils19
How I wish she find a way to tell him the truth. At least say something that will remind him who you really are!
Lya K
another trashy son of a b*tch like in Remarried Empress…. hope in time she leaves him… gets her evenge and finds someone more worthy of her… andI’ve a feeling she has been forced into this marriage and everything by her father.,.. oh well… let’s just wait and see….
blood_rose_21
I hate his bitchy attitude, its disgusting ugh🤮
Littleira
I hope he is not the ML
nozomiaoi13
you trash i hate u sm
ariana giyu
I WANT TO PUNCH HIMMMMMMM
Wtf?!
We need more can you update everyday?!
Hedgehog
This won’t be your typical manhwa where she’ll find another better guy … but I’ll still read it because of the novel
Ametrine
He just assumes she’s this arrogant person because of her father….Can’t wait for more chapters for a good reveal.
Ametrine
Too much verbal abuse…What did she do wrong? He hates her father…So why can’t he stop being so annoying and diverting all his hate on to her? Doesn’t look like she ever wanted to become empress. He could at least be respectful in the public eye. Can’t wait for a grand reveal for him to regret everything he’s said and done…He’s so childish for an emperor – he should focus on his JOB and stop whining….I personally want to slap his bitchy face.
Orgonite
Its not good.. Plss change ml..
MoonmistLuna
This was one of the few manhwas where I read the novel for it. I can’t wait😊😊😊
Roro😎
Tf his lover looks like his sister da fuq ew giving me very much remarried empress vibes
vivi
guys the mc is actually under the influence of black magic from her father, she wouldn’t act like this. The reason why she answers the Emperor with short answers is because thats the way she talked with the Duke, who got mad over everything so shott answers were a way to not make him mad
V is For Villainess
Well now I agree with the title
forgiveness996
Did everyone forget that the emperor was kidnapped by her father as a child? He jus needs to understand that shes not like her father.
Bjsn
Why doesn’t she get rid of that bish by some assasains .
St.Alessia
What a douche
tangakabahah
wtf tanginamong emperor ka. pag ayan yung ml patayin niyo nalang ako
moonlunar
i would drop this this is to infruriating but its so good please update
ari
LETS GOT THEY UPDATED!!
ari
YES ITS FINALLY NOT A PROMO!
kekeKey
so far I could understand why the emperor is acting like so
can’t wait for his character development
pipipipipi
this just the chapter 1 but this is already making me want to throw my phone grrr
ari
THAT MF-
pipipipipi
shit i’m gonna drop this i cant with the emperor
Britt
Ah now I get it why also her father has no shame
Britt
Is this gonna be like remarried empress because I get so much stress on that story
meowdusa
Hmm still so many gray area… need to wait for things to unfold… I can’t be like those judge polices, can i… XD
sakura Tree
i read the novel.. poor FL 😢😢
the father is devil
Okurrttt
And I actually thought that there wasn’t anyone more hateful than Sovieshitt Haaaaaaaa
Mikaela
even if i read spoilers that the emperor would change idc i still hate him to death. It’s not the good way to have revenge or what, if you hate the father you don’t have to drag someone and hate them too. It’s not that i can’t understand his feelings but yvonne have feelings too, she got humiliated.
Mikaela
maybe both parties had hard time but i can’t help but to worry abt yvonne.
deepikasymth
This is the most absurd toxic relationship that ever happened. YOU COULD AT LEAST TALK STUPID ,USE UR MOUTH .ASSHOLE EMPEROR
boobee666
istg if this shithead is the fucking male lead
Lovong
MY BLOOD IS BOILING LOL
I HOPE, AT THE END,THE EMPEROR FALL IN LOVE WITH THE EMPRESS BUT CANNOT HOLD HER ANYMORE. IT WOULD BE GOOD IF THE EMPEROR LIVE MISERABLY FOR HIS ENTIRE LIFE LOL
WHAT A GOOD WISH HEHE
‼️
This man has some audacity, I swear to god if he changes his decision later on I will be so pissed.
Yahyahyahboombayah
For the emperor himself he sure act childish. Always picking a fight with the empress and be mad when she only respond “yes” like sir shut up 😒
HaruHaru
i wanna rip his head
JapChae
She should say something like… “If she’s not smart enough to tell that you’re a married emperor, then, no. I disagree that she should help me with imperial duties.” or whatever.
Ehidk
Dont u just wanna ⚰💀🕴🏃♀️🤾♀️
Mikasa_Ackerman
Is the Emperor the end game? He’s a trash 😡
acuteag
I want to cry😭 She has to be the way she is for a reason. She was probably raised to be exactly how she acts.
Light356
This guy is so horrible!!
deanne01
I’ll come back to this when it’s no longer focused on a trash man abusing and trying to destroy some poor girl whose just doing what she thinks is her duty. Bring on his ruin, and the real ML. PLease. fortheluvagod.
It's nothing
What a bastard
It's nothing
^ so the father is a bastard
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
A… a.. aaaaa update came lol I am really happy btw thx. ((o(*>ω<*)o))
Johjoh
I’m boiling……..
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
Now I seriously think this piece of trash should be thrown in its place where it belongs to, even if someone tear this shit into pieces dogs won’t eat..🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪
Archduke
Glad i read the novel
Chibibear
Jerk that i can say 🙁
Chibibear
Hate!!!Hating someone like him silently it a waste of my emotion BS
ssnseries
I don’t hate anyone for now.
1st cuz of the title of the story
2nd cuz there have been no story from the perspective of the empress
I can’t wait for when we get to hear her side of the story.
Also i feel the way he is treating her is only because they lack communication and because he feels its right bcuz of his hatred towards her family….. Knowing the story from his side doesn’t make me hate him as of yet
iii
if this some kind of enemy to lovers trope imma drop it. gurl you better have revenge (ノ｀⌒´)ノ┫：・┻┻
Celeste
unbothered queen hehe
Lily
I think he is going to be ml I read in the novel but I really don’t like him even he is faking his relationship with that girl even so he is no one to treat empress like this.
FIONA
I don’t know what’s happening anymore.. Although it may seem like the emperor is trash- Well, He IS trash but there seems to be a reason why he treats the empress like so……the only reason why I try to be rational is because he’s the male lead T-T
kristyllava
I SWEAR THAT EMPEROR- also idk what to feel about the new girl its either she’s a bitch or a good person
ariana giyu
so he’s not as trashy i thought he would be ?
Yumebaka
He is so ugly even ginger is better
Le Tired
No he’s still trash, he does a lot more and at one point imprisons FL & assaults her in the cell but that’s halfway through the story. What happened to him at childhood was done by FL’s dad, not FL, and later in the book after there was still no evidence of FL working for her dad (instead she saved Kiana’s life by drinking poison in her place) he still suspects her anyway and holds her captive. She was trying to save her mom from her dad and b/c Karlois imprisoned her on baseless accusations, her mom died before she could get there.
————-
I’m also glad that people can stop hating on Kiana now. She tried to fix their relationship and improve FL’s image throughout the story but Karlois continued to dig his grave. She’s the real MVP honestly.
————————
Also spoiler:
FL was the missing girl ML was looking for the whole time. By the time he realized it, it was too late lol and he was like “what have I done???” Dumbass
Le Tired
Oh yeah the epilogue to this story is funny in a sad way. The author’s attempt to make Karlois look good was “the emperor was known to be a devoted husband to the empress. He carried her everywhere and never let her feet touch the ground” or something like that (it was short)
LIKE WOW, WHAT A GREAT HUSBAND. CARRYING HER EVERYWHERE MAKES UP FOR ALL THE VERBAL ABUSE AND HARRASSMENT SHE RECEIVED FROM HIM. Damn author
Nom
I have the URGE to throw this phone cuz of him
Izaya
Wow… They look like siblings
lavis
It is obvious that Fl has always been a pawn, she accepts everything you say because she has no other choice. If he thinks clearly, if she were someone who was always treated like a princess, there would be no way for her to accept certain situations. He’s looking for someone and we all know who he is.
happysloth1212
idk how the black-haired girl will turn out, but I like her more than the fl now
Vigne
Isn’t always like that even when the ML treat the FL like a fucking trash they always go back together. Sometimes it triggered me a lot
Anyway did she die? Le Tired
Sylle
I hate those btchs.
rin kurusaki
guys i highly recommend you to not read this , i read the novel and was about to break my laptop
. the way the empress act that way iiiss sooo saad , and the emperor is soo dumb and realise that empress is actually the victim until the end of story , and it was too late , anyway a lot hapened bcz male lead is dumb af
Fuckthisshit
After I read the spoiler here, I’m gonna drop this shit. It feels like ‘On the Emperor’s Lap’ or something. Especially the part that the ML is trash…. This is too annoying. Anyway, I don’t hate the girl whose is in the contractual relationship
Gojo
The emperor is not totally a trash ml ( I know y’all will hate me from saying this) except that he verbally abuse the empress but can you really blame him from doing so? He has his reasons why. The empress father killed his family and kidnapped him and almost killed him but the fl helped him escape that time. The ml still looking to the person who help him escape and he doesn’t know that it was the empress.
The fl is under control and been abused by the duke that’s why she can’t just spelled out to him that she was the person who help him.
But she will eventually try to do something that will remind him about the past.
yelena simp
so i think the one who saved him was the empress and she is the person he’s currently searching for, but, he doesn’t know that the person who saved him is the empress
Britt
I’m gonna give him the benefit of the doubt
Etherielle Laurel
Hmmm. I am of mixed opinions. On one hand, I think the Duke might actually turn out to be one of the most loyal of the noblemen, and simply trying to push a young heir into growing into his role. On another, he really did a good job convincing that kid he wanted to kill him. I think the kidnapping might have been completely destroyed because SHE got kidnapped too. Most of all, I’m just kind of sadistically looking forward to him losing her when he finally realizes what he has to lose.
Manhwa lover
So many comments about how the emperor is a trash. I currently don’t see any good thing about the empress as well. Both of them have bad qualities as of the moment.
Abyss101
i don’t know why but i have a feeling he did that intentionally to provoke her…..i just hope my hunch is true cuz i really don’t want another sovieshu or the king from lady to queen
Abyss101
also,,,,the art is pretty
Abyss101
i feel like she really isn’t a bad person and that maybe she said obedient in the sense that u know public mannerism or maybe not.
Abyss101
i feel like she is kinda shy or maybe he isn’t letting her speak cuz its just he thinks she is arrogant that’s all there is i mean i feel like he doesn’t want to listen to her side like at all….god this is so much like sovieshu
Abyss101
yeah i so totally knew he wasn’t in love with that girl i mean even sovieshu was in love and we could tell but this guy naah i knew it was a contract
also like the girl said he is searching for someone i have a strong feeling that when he was kidnapped the empress saved him or something and fell in love with him like and he so freckin gonna regret treating her that way…
Abyss101
also i don’t think he is trash he is just being what do i say discriminating or biased yeah more like he is extremely against the duke’s family …
Kuronight
K after i read @Le Tired, comment this will do be good and never return to this shit i really hate rape shit or abusive trash so if this is only about Mr. Motherfucker ML Abusing FL on baseless shit just later to still end up with her???????
Hell no i am out
kure
Im guessing this will be the 2nd of The Abandoned Empress.
Sopyy
Bullshit
Sopyy
Thanks for updating, i need moree
Eva
I wish whoever was translating would stick to translating this story more instead of only giving us 4 chapters and waiting a whole month to give us 1 chapter !!! If your gonna do something don’t half ass it that’s all I’m saying
superhotweeb
sovieshit 2.0 and trashta 2.0 😍😍
superhotweeb
Omfg I hate how he just assumes that the FL was treated like a princess. Like, what if there’s trauma linked to how she has minimal responses and just agrees. Like omfg
Yawa with respect
Ka yawa 😠
Ellie Edward
it really hurt when i read this. that bij doesnt hv hand to eat by herself 😒
Daphne
Asking if when are you always updating so maybe we can be updated to for the next chapter.😊😊
Mr.tenji
i hope the male lead realize that the female lead are nice
A
Geeze he’s such an ass…I’m trying to be open minded to see both perspectives but compared to other ml emperors, he doesn’t seem to really think about his actions and how they negatively effect his image. He’s so impulsive out of hate that he comes off immature. It’s fine to be upset but use that energy to get the duke punished for his crimes. You are the emperor…tf…even his employees do not agree with his actions. They’re way too harsh, especially when fl doesn’t even seem to be giving him any reasons to treat her in such manners. Don’t know if he’s redeemable at all at this point….
Gojo
She so pretty! And she’s trying to tell you something idiot!
Gojo
Well how does he know, for him the empress is the daughter of duke who killed all of royal family and almost killed him too, of course he’ll think that the duke is making his move again together with his daughter to snatch the throne as he always wanted it… yes he’s very harsh with his words with the empress but he never laid hands n her. He is waiting for the empress to give up as an empress without him making it obvious.
Y’all hate me or whatever I don’t care lol for me he has reasons why he acted that way!
Bix
Oh my god I meant that emperor is such an asshole mann someone please give him a piece of mind
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
umm, i somewhat don’t understand (¬▂¬)
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
Damn this man is really something which shouldn’t exist like really, i have never seen such personality. seriously, yes i do understand that he hold grudges against her family for personal reason but what the hell!! This is getting me strange vibes.
XliAce
How foolish. The parent’s heinous acts are not the child’s. I understand that she may be suspicious due the fact that shes the daughter of the duke but his actions are too harsh. At this point, I only wish that the Empress will be able to escape this hell peacefully and live happily or the Emperor redeems himself and realizes how foolish his actions are.
Gojes_Ellaine
Go to hell, a**holes!!!!💢
ariana giyu
bro ask her slowly what’s going on , dont push her around like she’s some tools
ariana giyu
for fuck sake ASK HER DONT BLAME HER
kristyllava
I fucking hate him so much I cant believe he’s our male lead
fiorella_sai
I really don’t like how their hair covers their eyes….
fiorella_sai
I think I prefer the novel over this manga atm. Besides, there’s already 21 chapters translated for the novel
Boy please
This foo makes no sense. He claims to hate fl but when Keana tells him to seduce fl to his advantage to find more info on the duke, he wanna say “oh but then once her father dies, she’ll have nothing since the love will also be a lie. Isn’t that too cruel?” Mf, you’re already cruel enough to her. If you hate her that much, why do you care?? Why are you trying to show some compassion now?? You’re already such an ass to her. Keana and everyone else are asking you to be nicer to fl but you refuse to because of your hatred for her and her father…but you’re not “cruel” enough to seduce her??? Man…he’s gotta be the stupidest ml emperor ever…
He trash
Ml at this point is irredeemable. He finds every chance and even makes up opportunities to basically harass fl for things she hasn’t/didn’t do. He has no evidence to blame her other than that she’s the duke’s daughter. His hatred for her is basically guilty by association which is so childish for someone who is emperor. I’ve been trying to see both perspectives but man, he is just so unnecessarily rude and unlikable. I like some heartache here and there with some chase but fl deserve so much better. And apparently things get even worse with ml…
Jigazha
Ugh! What the hell this jerk! I can’t take it anymore. At this point, he just know to blame the empress for anything now.
Manhwa Dads aficionado
This is the second time i dont wish the fl ended up with the ml..
The empress deserves someone far more better than the shitty emperor… what a pathetic excuse of a man
Flack
Bruuuuuuuuuh,,
F*ck the emperor!!! FUXKING f*ck him
And can’t we have a more clever empress? She’s actually a push over like bro?? He’s mistreating you and you just stay still? Can’t she do something? It’s like she’s powerless and even if she was powerless she can use her little brain
Gojo
No comment 😐
Janokis Badwater
Chill guys!
The fl can’t do anything as she is under influence of magic by the Duke himself which why she can only say things allowed by the Duke as she is only a tool for him.
But don’t worry about the ml guys. Once he found out that she is the person he is looking for the whole. That would be the greatest satisfying slap to his shiity face
Btw spoilers
Gojo
The empress poison herself and she’s the one who sent the letter to keana.
Haist too sad that the emperor didn’t notice when the empress push him at the garden entrance… there was incident in the past about rain fl save the ml , basically it’s a hint that the empress giving you idiot so you don’t regrets everything in the end!
yelena simp
i can’t wait to see his face when he finds out the truth about the empress!!!
yelena simp
@Boy please EXACTLY!! like what’s the logic in his words??
Rin Akaashi
Am I the only one who hates Queen whats her face
yelena simp
i think the one who sent the letter was the empress
Tea
Guys chill out the Fl rather live peacefully,how tf she wanna send a letter and poison herself man I mean she doesn’t want attention from anyone she just wanna live peaceful man. Therefore ML u really an asshole,even if she’s the duke’s daughter it’s doesn’t mean she was one of them who plan on harming u, this is why fl is stronger than ml man I really can’t thier Brain and common sense fr
I'm tired of these fake bitches
Bro fuck the ml he’s so annoying and petty
moonlunar
MORE PLEASE~
ViOleT
I just cant stand this ML u know….i want our empress to divorce him n go far away n let the emperor know the pain of losing her n not giving her love for all these years.
Orchidbliss
Let me guess. Hes looking for a girl that helped him when he was kidnapped but has no idea its his own wife? That hed regret it once shes gone, search for her blah blah. But treated her so pourly in the meantime
Zenni
This is what i been waiting for
Zenni
Hes more stupid than soveshit
ariana giyu
YOU’RE GOING TO REGRET YOUR WORDS MY GUYYY
ariana giyu
NOW YOU WANNA CARE
Zenni
Trashcan
Zenni
Stupid idiot trash bastard emperor ha ha plastic ka
kristyllava
I hate this guy sm
attakutti
I think the duke actually didn’t do any of that and probably played the villain so emperor will wake up and actually the pollen allergy of the Kaena girl was indication that pursuer of emperor was actually someone who. Had that.And the kaena is sus too.damn I bet this emperor is misunderstanding everything.
I hate the Duke too, sending the daughter there for whatever reason,plus I think she is not REAL DUKE’S DAUGHTER,she is probably someone who came 14 years ago.
Fck male lead
Spoiler
.
.
.
The ml regrets everything at the moment FL is about to die and days before that he has FL locked in a tower and verbally abuses her and tells the truth about his love being fake , FL begs him to trust her one more time and let her go(to save her mother)
Gojes_Ellaine
I just hopes FL will get the better man than that a**holes mf ML..
Yochi
gahh i want to get the empress out of that castle and bring her somewhere she can be free this shit is stressing me out
fiorella_sai
Why in the world does the artist like to draw eyes that are ALWAYS covered with some hair???!?!!!? Ahhhh that’s a bit annoying, but I will look past it, since I am curious to see how the characters will develop over time
Gojo
Ugh!
Bobbyboy32
What so he’s gonna play with her heart???
Luna 16
Fuck that jerk how dare he play with her feelings tsk tsk tsk i would be really surprised if she fell in love with him more i kniw i won’t
Fkthisml
Nah, I’m done. I’ve had enough with this ml. I just wanna slap his face hard when I see his face. I’m not reading this anymore
1-800-Choke.that.ho3
– Oh shit, here we go again.
Wtf?!
Ouuu he blushin’😏😏
Wtf?!
he legit blames the empress for everything the duke has done and the wrong doings inside the palace….
Wtf?!
My blood is boiling knowing that hes only pretending….
dripacquired
omfg
Bro
That fucking bitch he gonna use her love
Kitty
Ehem. FL is not really the real yvonee she is using by the Duke. Her Mother is sick that the evil duke take advantage of that thing. The real identity of the Fl is the long lost childhood love of the ML.
When the time comes. When ML knows her real identity and realize all the FL suffered from him and the duke. ML will feel so much guilty to the FL to the point that ML wants to end his life because of that guilt and love for the FL.
Its very sad story on FL.
– I Hate the ML because why he put on his anger to the innocent if you have a brain you should confronted the duke from the start. Ass**e
Bonani
Go to hell, emperor and keana.
loixox
better if marquis daughter and the empress become bestfrnds and dump the emperor
loixox
after this sovieshit seems to be a better person
loixox
you mfker!!!!this manipulative asshole is seriously pissing me off
Dugung
That trash is a bitch.
Sabby
UH PETITION FOR A NEW ML RN
Kardeal
trash
ariana giyu
BULSHIT DONT USE HER
fairy mf
LMAO F^CK THE ML SUCH A DUMBA$$ A$$HOLE
Lonely ~
Now that’s annoying
First of all fuck that father and that wizard
Second the emperor is not at the fault but he broke her heart several times and the thing that makes me angry so much is that the duke is the one who hurt you and killed your family not his daughter
It’s not his daughter’s fault so stop being such an asshole ^^
ViOleT
OMG PLEASE DONT LET HIM BE THE ML.
LET IT BE A DIFFERENT PLOT PLEASE.
LET HER GET DIVORCE WIT THAT TRASH EMPEROR N LET HER GET A MAN WHO IS WORTHY ENOUGH N STRONG ENOUGH TO PROTECT HER N LOVE HER VERY MUCH.
PS:but i guess tat’s not gonna happen cause we all know wat kind of story its gonna be.All the plots r all same.
deeyahoo
I want to punch the male lead pls-
He’s trash
Ml is just so unlikable. Have never came across such an unlikable ml until him. He says the duke wouldn’t have poisoned fl. How is he so sure about that??? But he thinks she poisoned herself. Huh??? What is with his logic?????? The duke has done things for him to suspect him but fl has not done anything to be suspected but he constantly blames her only..dude…can you not think logically for once??? He’s so trash….I don’t want her to end up with him. Ew.
Ee
Wanted to give the ml the benefit of the doubt because she’s under a spell and her mother is being threatened but his actions towards her are just so unnecessary and rude. If his actions were just a reaction from a misunderstanding then I can excuse it but his actions are provoked by his own bias hatred towards fl just being the duke’s daughter. He deliberately goes out of his way to be rude to her….he’s trash. Irredeemable.
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
arge!! Please don’t be blind by this man you know that too…please or i can clear that you are really and idiot….
celeenesilva
aggrrggggggggg damiitt . I wanna play squid game !!!
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
Damn this twist make me feel dumb …
yelena simp
noo! she’s even more pitiful now!!!
lavya
even though im not emotional it still brought tears down my eyesss……………………………….
chris.
well yeah, i know he have the reasons to hate the fl and soon will regret it but- you fcking bastard, a coward that only put your anger to a weak person that even can’t fight the duke with your power what a useless emperor are you?
Shame
FL, pls leave this shitty place and find someone who is truly love you and care about you
meeranad
bastard
meeranad
I’m not sobbing at 2am
BakemonoRis
WOW WHAT A TWIST
c
You f– a-sholeeee. I’ll burn you to death for using my sweet yvonneeeee
clink
the emperor and that woman look like siblings….
nozomiaoi13
i will still hate the ml even after he regret it.
Davi Felizardo
It was really obvious that she saved the prince in the past and that the duke was using her like a pawn. But boy oh boy, if the author even try to develop a relationship between this two I would be so angry that I will drop this shit, the prince behaviour is as bad as the Duke even when you know that he “forgot” her. For me just exist 3 appropriate endings: first she dies to fuck up the Duke and/or save her mother and the Prince, escond she survives and disapear with her mother at the end but not before given a really sweet reality check to the Prince and last but not least if the author wants to salvage any semblance of a romance story he ought to introduce another male lead, but taking in to account the cover and the chapters so far this is the most unlikely option ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Akane
AHHHHHHHH I HATEEE U, U BASTARD
Akane
TBH HE DESERVED THAT
Akane
AHHH CAN SOMEONE JUST SEMD HIS HEAD FLYING AWAY 😩🔫
Akane
I dont even feel a bit sympathy for you 🤡🔪
U deserved this traumatizing childhood
Akane
AHHH I AGREE THE EMPRESS IS PRETTY AND THE EMPEROR IS NOTHING BUT A SHITHEAD
wisteria
yay thank you for updating (●♡∀♡)
wisteria
ugh i want to shove a lamp up his ass
Tea
Guys can I get my knife pls I really can’t handle this ml and FL’s “father”
Aneliana
Saatnya menyumpah 🙂
karmadabi07
Even so, if the duke really treated the emperor like that, Yvonne has nothing to do with it, I now remember Sovieshu, another emperor who’s trash.
Goodandevy
I’m gonna drop this if he falls for her. Nobody deserves this kind of absolutely unwarranted abuse and the romantication of it is so damaging
Goodandevy
Freaking atrocious. This is a romantication of absolute abuse. The actions of the ML are not redeemable, not excusable. Even with the generic “boo hoo my past sucks” he goes out of his way to attack the FL. I can’t continue this with the thought that he will eventually be forgiven and the slate wiped.
Bunne
another trashta and soveshit species ❤️❤️
HEHE😈
Lemme guess, he’s doing all this for her ATTENTION!👹🔪
lovemaria
i know he has reason why he treat her like that but– isn’t a bit too much? I mean what is her sin to he treated like? Is being a daughter of the man he hates is her sins? I don’t get it where is he coming from. If the empress was like his father he’s been already poisoned and at his deathbed.
lovemaria
wtf he’s so childish blaming yvonne for everything, he doesn’t even care about her emotional situation. Does he know that the reason why she looked lifeless was because of him and her own father?!
lovemaria
I want to see him beg for the empress’ forgiveness when he founds out the truth. U bastard was cruel enough that she wish to die for you.
lovemaria
So why help her now? She drank the poison for you and your love!!!! Did u see what you did?!!! Then you always harass her wtf!!! Man wake up!!!! The parents fault isn’t a child’s fault too!!! She may be suspicious because she doesn’t show any emotions but you’re too cruel!! Even a kid knows if someone was suffering or not!! Are you blind?
lovemaria
Don’t play with her anymore. She’s already dead inside because of you and the father plus the curse. Stop playing with my yvonne. Nevermind i’ll just enjoy seeing you beg.
lovemaria
Just how much she needs to suffer? How much she needs to be hurt? Just please let her be happy because she was robbed. She deserves the world and the things it can offer. :))
Lady
Damn you guys are updating this slower than slow. I’m losing patience can you please update more
soppyyy
Yuaaaaa ouyyy lami kaayo patyon ang laki pisting yw
soppyyy
Ahhhhh sòoooooooooooooooooooooo stupid ml, i hope second ml will appear and fall in love at the first sight
And want to stole the heart of fl and give her a happy ending a happy life,family, freedom
𝕋𝕙𝕖 𝕊𝕚𝕞𝕡 ℍ𝕒𝕤 𝔼𝕟𝕥𝕖𝕣𝕖𝕕 𝕋𝕙𝕖 ℂ𝕙𝕒𝕥.
First?
MangaLover1
If I would have been in her place, no matter what I would have tried to tell Karl the truth.
But this is too much for my baby Lillian 😭😭😭😭😭
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
wahh it’s such a sad story ….(˃̵͈᷄⌓˂̵͈᷅) i hope everything will go fine
Tea
I will cured the ml
Gojo
I feel suffocated.
Abcd
From the earlier chapters I don’t think the emperor is bad
Jue
ML is worse than sovieshu. His useless cannot against the duke and put his anger to the innocent person. He is really trash.
터수키시마_케이
🕯️.
🕯️ 🕯️
Die die
🕯️ Die die die. 🕯️
Die.
🕯️. 🕯️
🕯️
This is my ritual to you…
터수키시마_케이
Not what I expected but okay ㅠㅠ
Nyx
Yesss!!! I hope that branch gonna hit him to death. So we all can have another ML. An ML that has brain, not only d**k like him.
YonaOfTheDawn
I am sorry but is he supposed to accept her. Her father is the one everyone should be angry at. He knows he is selling his daughter but he wants her to be treated well. If he loved his daughter he wouldn’t have given her to someone who doesn’t like or doesn’t even want to marry her. And also the girl knows her situation so if she has some other expectations then its her fault now. Apparently the Duke killed his family members so is he supposed to entertain his daughter. I mean come on!
yeni_uwu
no ;-;
Etherielle Laurel
Huh. Poor girl. This is a horrible situation, with no real method of resolution apparent. So what outlier is going to get thrown in to shake things up?
soppyyy
Thanks for updating
shiineeeee
oml the last time i got this angry i think it was trashtas appearance or something?
shiineeeee
i kinda get him actually who would wanna marry the daughter of a person who is the murderer of his family, kidnapped him when he was a kid and greedy for power? and she too acts arrogantly it cannot be helped i guess? i mean she also have troubles with that trash like father. just imagine yourself in his place.
shiineeeee
i completely understand why he is acting like a mf and i think his goal is to humiliate her seeing his frustration whenever she says “yes”.
shiineeeee
I’m trying to be in his frickin side because he is the damn ml, but just cause you were traumatized in the past doesn’t mean she deserves to. but at some point i do understand him…..
like imagine yourself sitting next to the student whose parent killed your family and kidnapped you once? Would you be like oh here take my stuff lets be “best friend forever”?? obviously no but here his situation is worse cause he is married to her.
shiineeeee
who tf made him the emperor when he cannot understand human language??
shiineeeee
that is veryy unnecessary!!! if you hate someone at least do it fuckin whole heartedly
shiineeeee
PAin bot.
isobel
‘youre out of touch, im out of time’
ssnseries
Get lost u jerk
FaquiO
If you read the novel congratulations, but
We would relish our reading without so many spoilers thanks
scarletulip
uwaaa poor the fl please stay strongg
Kali
Fuck you~ and yoy and youu~ i hate you face and she now hates youuu~
tea.
even if he cry a blood tears i will never ever ever forgive him
tea.
I swear if she forgive him I would drop this
Navia
Such a sad story
Navia
I hope she lives a happy life
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
It’s soo sad (˃̵͈᷄⌓˂̵͈᷅)
Red flag 🚩
Is he the ML? He is in the cover.
ariana giyu
i wanna kill him
ashleyyy_
Please fix the grammar
やあ、૮꒰ ⸝⸝´ ᵕ ` ꒱ა ⋰˚☆♡
😭😭
erikatakeru
i really wanna hug her and give her a pat at the back.
An
😰😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
An
I just want everything to be alright 😢😢😢😢😢😢
yummy_mahoe
Can we just have another ML, please?
scarletulip
i want to give her hug 🥺🥺
Pooja
Why the author writes these sh*t scripts where fl are blind and don’t see their worth rather showing they are powerful and worthy.
Tazya
Does she really not care about her?
Amandline
The ML is pure garbage. Nothing he can do will make this better. Give us another one pls
Etherielle Laurel
Right, so I’m still seeing a lot of blaming the ml. I don’t like him either, but can we at least direct some of the flamethrower’s damage at the duke? THAT FLAMING BOIL ON A COW’S TAIL AS IT BOLTS THROUGH A FIELD OF DRIED GRASS I mean AAAARERRRRRRRRRRRRGGGGGGHHHH!!! JUST STICK ONE OF YOUR OWN MAIDS IN THERE AS A SPY IN RETURN FOR SPENDING MORE TIME WITH HER!!!
crackeradd
So far, I kinda wish this was called “They Both Die in the End” where the duke and emperor dies 🙂
jiral
There’s an easy solution isn’t it? Either kill yourself or kill the Duke. Things will end right there and then. When you dead, you won’t know anything that comes after that. Why make things complicated.The magician only made you unable write/say what you aren’t allowed to say/write. You’re not barred from doing anything else. Can’t the author be more creative than this? This lowers your IQ in the negative.
jiral
There’s an easy solution isn’t it? Either kill yourself or kill the Duke. Things will end right there and then. When you’re dead, you won’t know anything that comes after that. Why make things complicated.The magician only made you unable write/say what you aren’t allowed to say/write. You’re not barred from doing anything else. Can’t the author be more creative than this? This lowers your IQ in the negative.
AlexTheCrystal
i hate this so much soon he is gonna find out who she is and then he will feel terible ahe will leave but come back cause she loves him i hate these why would he play with her heart like that its not her fault its her dads
Kardeal
Imma gonna drop this it s really fruking toxic i hate ml so much i hope fl die n wish ml suffer his whole life
Gojo
Haist!
Navia
The ml didn’t even tried to know her personality or problems its totes not cool
lei
this guy is so in love with himself, he got a mistress who looks just like him lol pft what a narcissist
Minari
The ML dosent even try to understand her. He was like “oh i hate her father so i’ll just hate her too” i mean like srsly
Haryta
I’ve read book. Tbh I think it’s worth waiting (?). It’s a very slow romance and the ml was fucking annoying but he will pay the price eventually.
Yandere-oneesama
Male lead is totall trash 🗑️😤
Yellow purple
I hate this..poor fl
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
Arge seriously i have never seen such a asshole person in my whole life. It’s getting kinda annoying(>_<)
Yellow purple
Jerk 🤬🤬
Yellow purple
I really hate him ..jerk😛😛
Yellow purple
Someone kill this jerk…the empress deserve someone better😡
Yellow purple
I hate everyone escept the fl ..
Yellow purple
😭🤧🤧🤧
Yellow purple
😭🤧
Yellow purple
😡i’m so angry i hate the ml so much .
Fatima Butt
Please don’t be ML 😩 i already hate you
Sinnybun
I want to hold out and see how this goes, but this ml is such an ass! And the fl is really just wallowing and allowing it all.
To top it off the translation is dizzying and half the time I have to read the text and then rework it in my mind to try and make it fit…
Think I’ll have to drop this one
Alessandra LEE
@Haryta
What’s the name of the book is it the same as this.
shiineeeee
I’m still waiting for him to suffer and that is the sole reason I’m reading this shit.
misspanda907
TRASH!
Shownomore
F*ck this guy really gets in to my nerves
Telliton
I am utterly baffled by the amount of people who hate this man. He has been forced into a marriage he doesn’t want, with someone who keeps telling him to ‘obey’ her father like what would that look like to anyone?
I’m already anticipating that she’s trying to minimize the damage and protect him from her father or something, but how the fuck is HE supposed to know that? Sure he doesn’t let her talk or spend any time with her but would YOU wanna spend time with the person you were literally forced to marry!?
Why do people cheer everything a female LI does, no matter how downright evil and will just forget about it a second later– but the male LI who has a perfectly good reason to hate her is a ‘bastard’?
Like I remember from multiple stories where they were a ‘villainess’ and had blackmailed the ML in the past– and the ML reacted to them accordingly but now they’re a ‘different person’ so they should just be forgiven even though nobody could possibly know that!?
Ugh.
Iruma
Oh you fucking ass The Audacity he has you are like piece of shit
Catherine
Communication is the key, the FL must try more to express her feelings, the ml must shut the fucking hate thingy it was her father not her he fucking didn’t thingking the FL feelings. And that fucking trash duke, u dont deserve to be called a father in any perspective 😃
Telliton
I think this actually outlines the difference between a cruel man and a man who’s been forced into a terrible situation where he acts out to feel in control.
He doesn’t actually want to hurt anyone that doesn’t deserve it, but he’s sure she DOES in the case of like ‘neglect’ because he thinks she doesn’t love him and just wanted the seat of Empress and that she and her father worked together to force him into this position.
So he believes she deserves to be told ‘I don’t love you and never will’ and be treated like shit because she made his life harder and more unbearable, but he draws the line at doing things that will actually ruin her whole life.
To his mind, it doesn’t matter if he treats her like a stranger or someone he hates, because she just wanted the Empress seat and was in cahoots with her father who killed his entire family.
And once again people are reacting to this like he’s a complete piece of trash. Too many simplistic plots with clear ‘good’ and ‘evil’ have taught Manhua readers to expect that pattern everywhere and in everything.
Telliton
He doesn’t hate her because ‘guilt by association’ he hates her because she married him in a forced marriage. He takes every opportunity to say ‘be careful or I’ll oust you’ because he has no control over the fact that she’s his wife and the Empress.
Basically this guy is backed into a corner and is lashing out at everyone in order to feel safe. That’s not irredeemable.
He’s not even really cheating on his wife. Like, he could and it’d be perfectly valid as she and her father forced him into it to begin with and he shouldn’t be forced into a marriage he doesn’t want.
And I say ‘she and her father’ because of that shit in the beginning. ‘I’ll discipline him well’ like how the fuck is a person supposed to take that? He assumed it meant they were in cahoots and she was just as arrogant as her father and to be honest I would think so too if I didn’t sense a twist in here somewhere.
Like I think they’re both victims but the only person who knows that is her. He thinks he’s the only victim, and that’s like at least 50% her fault for not fucking saying anything. She has had the perfect opportunity to open up and at least ask him questions and get a convo going and she just. Doesn’t.
Telliton
See now this is a beautifully tragic story about two people who are both fucked and hate the situation they’re in but all I can see is recrimination toward the guy who is only lashing out because of what’s been done to him. Everybodys’ got sympathy for the Empress, and it’s not like she doesn’t deserve it, but if you see this as all black and white with him being trash for lashing out, then you miss the nuance of the situation which makes the story that much better.
Gojo
The watermark kinda annoying too much.
Gojo
They’re wearing a short short short.
ariana giyu
im tired of him
Bibiii
I understand how he hates her father and now her but publicly shaming her and degrading her or giving her emotional wound won’t help him either lmaooo he just wants to stay in this fantasy world and cheats
ariana giyu
i HATE him
ariana giyu
i HATE the OLDER him
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
Ehh kinda feel like deja vu but i just checked that this is somewhat kind of repeating with a little difference.
shiineeeee
well i understand him but i still want her to die or like disapear so that he can suffer what she suffered all these years
shiineeeee
well he sure is gonna be heart broken when he realises the truth
makengko
when tf is he gonna realize AAAA IM FUCKING PISSED
Let me kill that bitches
Well everyone know that…someone will appreciated it when people he or she love gone. STUPID EMPEROR !! WAKE UP!! YOU DUMBASSS !! I DON’T WANT TO KNOW THAT YOU GONNA CRY UNTIL BLOOD TEARS..WHEN YOU KNOW SHE IS THE ONE YOU MISS. BUT THAT TIME IS TOOOOOOOO LATE !! YOU DUMBASS !! DON’T TREAT OUR BABY LIKE THAT. UGRHH
Silly
Tell the person who did the translation to please get plenty of rest please!!
shiineeeee
fuck that damn duke
W0NDER
first !
shiineeeee
well you dumb bastard get ready to cry your eyes out in the future and regarding the ml I dont hate him infact I completely understand him.
like imagine yourself sitting next to the student whose parent killed your family and kidnapped you once? Would you be like oh here take my stuff lets be “best friend forever”?? obviously no but here his situation is worse cause he is married to her.
and he still thinks that she is working for her father and the fl is not at all communicating which is making the matters worse. so to sum it up both MCs are dumb and its better for both of them to die, it is said that the fl will die
Nunneko
This started out good but its moving at a slow and boring pace im losing my interest
Nivea
If you’re reading this then your parents will die in 5 years. To undo this curse you have to paste this comment on 5 more Manga. I’m so sorry please forgive me
Ma chan
Another trash !!! God
khalisha
this is just sad-
Yoonnie Hazel
Omg finally an update !! I already miss Yvonne / Lilian so much TvT
Gojo
@shineeeee I totally agree with you.
Gojo
Ugh waiting for the ml to recognize her!!
Kakali
What’s your problem dude?
Kakali
I mean he does have a reason. People might say that it’s the Duke who did the harm not his daughter. But it’s apparently hard for him to forget what he went through because of his. Also he mentioned how many royals were killed. So his reaction towards her is not at all something for what he needs to get called a trash. I understand and I’m looking forward.
Kakali
If he doesn’t ask, she doesn’t speak either. Like who do you think you can blame? Both are unbothered. Lol
Kakali
One of the dumb emperors I’ve come across. Not very supervising. Have seen worse lol
Kakali
Now that’s a foul play.
Kakali
I see now.
Kakali
The sense of helplessness is eating me from inside
Kakali
It’s sad
Kakali
I guess it’d be too late when he realises. And I wish for nothing but that.
Kea
i dont want a redemption for ml i just want to see his heartbroken face and him begging for her
Kian
Can’t really hate the emperor at this point. He was forced into a marriage he hated by a murderous duke who even kidnapped him once, to the duke’s own daughter. He is a puppet, he knows it, and hates it. Expecting him to be understanding of the duke’s daughter’s circumstances is unreasonable. I’m sure she has her own tragic past that the emperor is unaware of, since the duke obviously sent her into a hellish marriage for no clear reason. The duke even seems a bit dumb at this point, since such a marriage won’t actually benefit him.
The empress herself seems to understand why she is hated and is just passively doing her own thing, aware that she has no real power. Her passivity may even be a way to get back at her father.
ThUnwantedOpinion
Oh my god someone change the ML right now
Jubel
WTF
Jubel
F*ck all of you except my fl
Jubel
I always wonder if she couldn’t say the truth, couldn’t she write it down on paper.
Jubel
Idk it’s my opinion
crackeradd
@ kakali @ kea I completely agree with both of you. I don’t want that ml
Manhwa_lover
I agree too😢
Shaka
If you’re reading this then your parents will die in 5 years. To undo this curse you have to paste this comment on 5 more Manga. I’m so sorry please forgive me
TO THE PERSON WHO DID THIS ASSHOLE. 😩 I’m only doing it cause people out here can be doing witch craft & I believe it
Shyuna
I dont know why i very very very very very very hate the ml
The ml is bastard just want to using yvonne
i wish yvonne to be badass and marry a better man than that ml
𝕀𝕥ℤ_𝔸𝕣𝕖𝕦𝕞
I am sure he is gonna regret using her and so so so soooooo
Comics
I’m not too fond of the ML, looking forward to seeing him suicide
Lo
From the novel, this is gonna be a long long time of torture to see FL suffer and finally break down by ML’s betrayal.
-mila-
BROOO her past is so sad and that man is making her future sad too? Wtff my beautiful lady is so mistreated T^T
Senpai pirirurrpurara
BITCH IM ALREADY IRRITATED U MOTHERFUCKER GO DIE IN A DITCH.
GAYS WE KNOW WHAT TO DO, GET THE FUCKING CARS AND KNIVES. I WILL GET TORTURE CHEMICALS READY, WERE GONNA BURN AN ASSHOLE.
hannnnnnnn
If you’re reading this then your parents will die in 5 years. To undo this curse you have to paste this comment on 5 more Manga. I’m so sorry please forgive me
manhwa_addict
you son of a bword seriously you decided to go that road!! how can he be so stone hearted!!
raniveluv
what an asshole of an ML. he better have the best redemption arc in existence for me to even consider liking him.
manhwa_addict
this is making my blood boil too much!
shiineeeee
tf why is everyone hating the ml again? didnt you guys read the story? he is the ml and will continue to be if you are just gonna be haters just dont read it at all..
.
like i said who would be friendly with the daughter of the man who slaughtered his family? even if this was a fairytale, there’s absolutely no way that he can accept her.
if i were in the ml’s position, I’ve do the same.
she must prove herself and make him see that, that’s the only way
shiineeeee
then again his plan is dumb
sora
i hope ml khs smh i hate him sm hes blind >:((
Yumi
>!The ML doesn’t change his ways until after the FL’s mother passes away (who kills herself to break the Duke’s
hold and the spell he has on her daughter) and he learns the truth about the FL’s identity. That she was his childhood friend all along.!<
Rory
Hello! Do you know where we can read the complete novel? Thks
Nyx
📛 Hey author❗We need another gentleman to replace this sh*tty ML. Someone with brain & heart, not only d**k like this one.
Nnsyrahh
Pleaseee where the second male lead i need him now asap!!🗣
Babyharryy
kinda Giving me the vibe from the emperor laps 🙄
shiineeeee
pfftt ml is just dumb so dumb that he cant even be a 2nd ml but what to do I have to suck it up so i wont die of heartbreak in the end.
.
and she is determined not to let him know the truth so idk anymore. at this point this is so slow
shiineeeee
what? is that dumbass realizing it? if he realize it that would be the end of the world. at some point I support him but he is just dumb he should try to get rid of the duke not target the queen but he is the ml of this tragic verse so be it. Although I understand him his methods are wrong
shiineeeee
I come her to vent my pent up anger
shiineeeee
*here
Akane
Just fck off already 💀🔪
CatGirl
How much longer till he eats dirt?
Akane
Bruh your still a trash cause thats not a way you should treat a lady….
crackeradd
I wonder how much chapters tills take for him to realize she is Lou
crackeradd
also, how long would it take for him to figure out that he’s using Vyonne to look for Lou (who is Vyonne) and that he had been married her this entire time
Doo
I need some spoilers
Haryta
I’ve been summoned ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Nah Just kidding. I read the book long time ago so I don’t really remember much details. Anyway yall need to chill. He gonna fell in love with her soon (but still treated her like shit 😭😭😭) We still have a long way to go. When he discovered she’s Lou, he already broke her trust and disappoint her. He even locked her in jail bfore. Girlie gonna fell into depression and blamed him for her mother’s death bla bla bla anyway but eventually like any other fairytales, they gonna comeback to each other I spilled to much sorry
Kea
@shinneeee i get what u mean though u dont treat someone like shit cuz their dad did something wrong him getting a concubine is wife thats normal but he treats her horribly
Kea
@Shyuna sadly yvonne cant do anything to much cuz she is threatened (her mom will die if messes up)
Darkness
Because she’s Lu are you dumb or something😒😒
kazuhamybeloved
I’m sorry but i really wish for the father and ml to drop dead by now. At this point just give the fl her time and space, stop trying at this point
Jubel
when is he going to realize
kazuhamybeloved
I find that this is the right moment to have a second ml and swoop her of the palace or ditch the ml
Darkness
He’s the one of the asshole ml I have ever seen😒😒
devilchild35
I am waiting until he realizes the truth. That day will be glorious!
Harlequinn
idk dude they seem pretty god damn similar XD
Nelcy
Woahh..+A grade trash!
shiineeeee
again? I enjoyed the tragedy and stuff but now the story is too slow
shiineeeee
i read a comment before saying that the fl was betrayed and stuff so his dumb plan will work? I’m waiting for that now.
Darkness
I slightly hate that bastard king😒😒
Mariza
@Darkness if slightly means to slap him 10 times in the face and ask him how dumb he is then I too slightly hate him
-mila-
bro just fucking cut your hair or put your maid to write the words for you to tell his shit-ness abt this it literally is that easy
Cherrys_blossom
AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAGHGGHGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHGGHA WHY THE FREAKING GOOD LORD WHY AM I DOING THIS TO MYSELF?!!!! F*CK THAT BASTARDDDD UGHHHHH HE’S SUCH A DESPICABLE AFSJDGAKSKSJSIEKDJSJSHKS ┻━┻ ︵ヽ(`Д´)ﾉ︵ ┻━┻
Lisa varghese
Every time I see chapters labeled 12.5 14.5 etc I know the translation is about to be shit
depressed_reader
I hate to say this but ml is hypocrite.
Nnsyrahh
I don’t know why this IDIOT can be king 😋WE need a smart king not a STUPID king🤗🤗
kazuhamybeloved
this ml makes me want to punch the wall but make it his face instead
Gojo
Y’all know she can’t get away either way right, because of her mother.
ariana giyu
bul- you already forgot her the moment you saw her again
yelena simp
she’s gonna realize that he still remembers her!!
ariana giyu
bij doesnt even try to talk to her and just try to use her
ariana giyu
just choke him yvonne, you’re the one who needs revenge right now
Gojo
I know right! Why not try to take the duke down first, after that he can decide if the queen is enemy or not. Ugh can’t to see him be heartbroken because of how he treat the queen.
ariana giyu
this dude really know nothing
ariana giyu
ew
ariana giyu
idiot idiot idiot
ariana giyu
that effing duke srsly doesn’t know his own place
Candy girl
More than the male lead, the commenters are asshole here.. Seriously.. You guys are cursing him when you don’t know what he have gone through? I bet each one of us would do the same if we had childhood trauma..
ariana giyu
oh but BIJ YOU DIDNT EVEN RECOGNISED HER YOU IDIOT
Gojo
Yeah can’t she write about the real her? Or someone will, and yeah cut her hair short and don’t take a bath for months perhaps the color of her hair would changed like when she was young. Haist I don’t know anymore.
Gojo
Omg how long I’m gonna wait we’re only chapter 25.
KIRA
Are we gonna wait until 100 chapters so the guy will recognize her AHHHHHHHHH
kazu<3
the emperor can eat shit
kazu<3
what the fuck? This mf just straight up asked if a woman stranger can sit with them for lunch? bro does he think this is somekind of picnic??
kazu<3
” I was so immersed in this feeling of love that i am experiencing for the first time” 🤮🖕
Etherielle Laurel
I’m fine with waiting longer for him to recognize her. I’m mean, but I want him to SUFFER for blaming her for her father’s actions
Miljana
Omg I’m getting do pissed 😡 retarde pitaj je prvo šta je bilo saslušaj malo idiote glupi uff
Miljana
Pička
nahri
i believe she may be an illegitimate child or something of the sort and that her father actually treats her roughly, just a guess tho
nahri
i am disgusted beyond words
Celestine Lyvoenne
Hello I can be Ur Cleaner or Redrawer since im good at it, Please contact me.
Darklight0013
I agree with Etherielle Laurel
Nnsyrahh
Another adrien???😾👊🏻
I am Interested
Aah get me isekaied, I will yeah that duke a hell of a lesson!!
Our FL is the best😭😭
I am Interested
OK the ML is the worst, He fails…NEXT!!!
I am Interested
Give us another ML
Onmylaptop247
Everyone says that it’s too toxic and annoying, but having read the book IT’S WORTH THE WAIT, AND IT’S A SLOWBURN SO HAVE PATIENCE IF YOU WANT TO CONTINUE READING
shroomiee
I don’t want this ugly bastard to be the ml 💀
shroomiee
I hope this guy just drops dead ngl
shroomiee
yh I rlly cant do this anymore it’s clear the author will try to give the prince a pathetic attempt at a “redemption” buts he’s so selfish and shitty nothing can fix what he’s put fl through he’s trying to “win her over with love” but even that’s a pathetic failure since he’s blaming her for things she can’t control and blatantly saying he dislikes her 💀 irs obvious he’s a mistake and I hope he rots in hell and maybe kill himself bc of how embarrassing he is while he’s at it I rlly want a different ml in this story but it’s obvious that’s not gnna happen 😭
shroomiee
piece of fucking shit this guy is I hoped fl would somehow break free of the spell tell the truth and then leaves and a new person falls in love with her and the emperor regrets it and gets jealous and tries to get her back but she doesn’t give a shit abt him anymore that would be alot more satisfying then this, (I’m sorry but it’s true) crap novel
ariana giyu
i just want her to be happy why is it so hard🥲🥲🥲
yuki san
Lol u will regret treating her like that,dude
Kea
i hope they get a divorce
Etherielle Laurel
Mmmmm, I’m just waiting for him to find out, he’ll punish himself more than we could ever hope to once he does
˚ ༘♡ ⋆｡˚
I like the back and fourth view of perspective because there isn’t a dead set perspective you can kind of get the story from both sides, As of now, it’s funny how they both make each other angry. It’s probably what makes this story stand out for me personally.
Wtf?!
I hope he can realize now…
shiineeeee
well my patience is running out so she better die now so that he can suffer
shiineeeee
lol everyone got used to this dumb ml and is already waiting for the redemption arc😂😂😂
shiineeeee
well I didn’t understand the last part
ariana giyu
bij YOU IDIOT HOW TF DID YOU EVEN BECOME THE EMPEROR
Lover of Medea💜
I DIDNT KNOW SOVISHIT FROM REMARRIED EMPRESS HAD A SHITTY ASS BROTHER!
Lover of Medea💜
WHY DO THEY ALWAYS THE CHILD?! LIKE BISH JUST BECAUSE THEIR PARENTS WERE SHIT IT DOESN’T MEAN THEY ARE!
Lover of Medea💜
AH THIS BITCH!
Lover of Medea💜
To those saying it’s not all the emperor’s fault, I agree but his so convinced that Yvonne is exactly like her father, like why do they always think the child will be the same as the parent?! Like he should have met her before out right judged her!
Lover of Medea💜
I’m sorry but the author is a damn bastard! Like I just read the spoilers and what the actual fuck is wrong with him?!
YaeMikosTiddies
whos yvonne? a flower ?
Certified clown
What happened to the chapters
Kea
yvonne is the fl or fake other queen?/
O w O
Yvonne is the fl
ssnseries
Hope . That tiny teeny sliver of hope 🤩.. plsss before it’s too late 🙏
devilchild35
I count the days until he realizes the truth and starts paying for all his shitty behavior!
Lottie_Jeffrey
Hmm. I wonder if this is worth to read 🤔
tamlor
tamlor 7e67e646ff https://wakelet.com/wake/-uUxwoyvJDi5gENaDOls8
Gojo
His majesty just need to fart 💨
Nyx
📛 So in political aspect, our ML is a weak king for sure.
And what’s with his small feminine waist tho‼️😂
Gojo
Why can’t he just kill him right there just turn into a tyrant emperor so problem solve!
Eris
FUCK THE OLD MAN FUCK THE EMPEROR AND FUCK THE CONCUBINE FUCK EVERYONE IN THIS MANHWA
MALE LEAD FUCKING DUMBASS
_mila-
bro-It’s so sad to see her so miserable in the place where she thought it would be her way out of the hell she was at home T^T
Alexa Heart
Okey I am getting frustrated, can someone give me a spoiler, when is the Male Lead going to realize who she is
Gojo
Oh still a long way to go before he found out bout her. He actually fell for her but he was so adamant bout his feelings and his hates towards the duke made him blind. Not until the fl was released from magic then he was convinced.
This story actually will torture the readers slowly from frustration.
ariana giyu
i still hate you
ariana giyu
its always the shitty people that’s hard to die
ariana giyu
i really want to hug her🥲🥲🧎🏻♀️
Lune R
i think this is going to be long anyone know where the novel is
luoxun
DON’T READ THIS COMMENT, just another annoying chain I’m too paranoid not to do.
If you’re reading this then your parents will die in 5 years. To undo this curse you have to paste this comment on 5 more Manga.
Eris
the ml fucked up
_mila-
Fuck you bitch .HOW DARE YOU GIVE OUR QUEEN A GLIPSE OF HOPE THEN TAKE IT AWAY LATER , truly a monster….
An
I’m usually very very open minded with mls who are written with harsher personalities and misunderstandings since there’s context to why they act like that…but this ml….no no no..he’s just trash. Irredeemable. Some of the things he did to her was just to be straight up petty. No rhyme or reason. He was just straight up being a paranoid douchebag.