Rating
The Duchess of the Glass Greenhouse Average 3.6 / 5 out of 1K
Rank
N/A, it has 284 monthly views
Alternative
Duchess of the Glass Greenhouse / 유리온실의 공작 부인
Author(s)
Artist(s)
Updating
Type
Updating
Summary
The Duchess of the Glass Greenhouse
Reina was born from a high noble lineage and became the wife of Duke Heathville. However, she faces a miserable death in which she is despised by her loved one, and even her child is taken away from her. But when Reina finally gave up on everything…she was given a second chance. «This time, I won’t turn a blind eye to whatever I see!» Reina summoned her courage and began to live her second life. « Edhart. I know everything now, and I hate you.» Reina realizes now how ignorant she was in the past. “I’m going to divorce you.” Even the husband that she once loved. “Alright.” Her husband, who she thought had despised her, was crying.
- Duchess of the Glass Greenhouse
- 유리온실의 공작 부인
Search for series of same genre(s)
Welcome to S2manga site, you can read and enjoy all kinds of Manga trending such as Drama, Manhua, Manhwa, Fantasy, v.vv…, for free here. All of the manga new will be update with high standards every 24 hours. If you are a Comics book (Manga Hot ), S2manga is your best choice, don’t hesitate, just read and feel !
Show more
- Chapter 79 November 17, 2022
- Chapter 78 October 6, 2022
- Chapter 77 September 30, 2022
- Chapter 76 September 26, 2022
- Chapter 75 September 15, 2022
- Chapter 74 September 3, 2022
- Chapter 73 August 25, 2022
- Chapter 72 August 22, 2022
- Chapter 71 August 11, 2022
- Chapter 70 August 11, 2022
- Chapter 69 July 22, 2022
- Chapter 68 July 14, 2022
- Chapter 67 July 14, 2022
- Chapter 66 July 8, 2022
- Chapter 65 June 23, 2022
- Chapter 64 June 23, 2022
- Chapter 63 June 10, 2022
- Chapter 62 May 26, 2022
- Chapter 61 May 20, 2022
- Chapter 60 May 16, 2022
- Chapter 59 May 5, 2022
- Chapter 58 May 4, 2022
- Chapter 57 April 14, 2022
- Chapter 56 April 10, 2022
- Chapter 55 April 10, 2022
- Chapter 54 March 26, 2022
- Chapter 53 March 26, 2022
- Chapter 52 March 7, 2022
- Chapter 51 March 7, 2022
- Chapter 50 February 23, 2022
- Chapter 49 February 23, 2022
- Chapter 48 February 23, 2022
- Chapter 47 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 46 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 45 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 44 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 43 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 42 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 41 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 40 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 39 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 38.5 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 38 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 37.5 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 37 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 36.5 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 36.1 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 35 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 34 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 33 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 32 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 31 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 30 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 29 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 28 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 27 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 26 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 25 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 24 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 23 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 22 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 21 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 20 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 19 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 18 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 17 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 16 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 15 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 14 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 13 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 12 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 11 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 10 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 9 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 8 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 7 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 6 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 5 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 4 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 3 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 2 January 6, 2022
- Chapter 1 January 6, 2022
Show more
MANGA DISCUSSION
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE
KiellY
I hope this updates quickly
KiellY
Happy birthday btw ❤🙃
Nikita
It’s not her fault dude.A carriage broke in thin air! Don’t you think someone can be behind it but know you are just gonna blame your child daughter..why coz she is girl?
ereen
wow i already love this first chapter 😀 cant wait to read the next one! also ticket before this is famous? say here hehe
ereen
wow who r u to blame someone for what they DIDNT do, blame the road, the rocks, or the driver 😐. like bro gtf outta here gotta ruin shi
Tsukii
Why you here eren? Did you tranform to this world?
Tsukii
And i love this manhwa already
manga-lover
omgggg they created such mystery
manga-lover
another dumb douche dad i see
Tsukii
Can’t wait for more chpter 😉
Alyawils19
Yeah or blame the horse
Maria
Another sad story? My heart can’t endure it.
dane123
i love manhwa even if I’m on the 1st chapter
dane123
i’m about to cry
EpP1d
Sounds exciting!
Bird poop
Such a bastard ! How could he rob a mother from her child and give him to another woman at that !!!
UnknownLaury
I don’t blame him from taking the child tho…how can you take care of a child you can’t even touch 🤷🏾♀️
klobber
Couldn’t care less about the story, but my favourite castle with the arch is there, so I guess I will read it all.
yeni_uwu
dang ; -;
yeni_uwu
I cannot with these types, like gtfo bruh
yeni_uwu
He better make up for his last life of idiocy istg
RASUBA
I hate trashy ml but I do like them at the same time but I do hate him for now
Tsukii
Trashy ml ughh
meowdusa
Just curious… why ppl keep comparing their modern morals n norms with these mangas/manhwas/manhuas (fantasy historical genre)? Women back then werent highly valued like these days…. right?
?????
hate to break it to you but babies don’t always cease their crying just because it’s their parent holding them. elle was just a few days old when the father thought that was enough evidence to rob a mother of her child…
StrikerElite
I hope she spends her life with her child this time. 🙂
Haiko
I’m sorry but the ML is, for now, so trashy. So what, he’ll become fond of her because she’s suddenly distant ? Typically what I hate but I still want to see the MC happy with her child so I’ll continue for now. Even if I’d like it if he doesn’t come back in her life like a flower who’s suddenly in love
Toga
I can’t wait for the following chapter !!
Alyawils19
More please
Raven Perez
I really went to read more I hope it updates faster
Kuroko
I dont really want a cliche story where Fls child father becomes a wonderful husband after all he did and would do we see clearly what trash he is for doing a deal where he gets what he wants and thinks about a fucking future bitch next to him its disgusting i dont want a ML like that at least in other mangas like “50 tea recipe” that ML was never so low to get a mistress cant really understand this its just shows these ML have no respect for there wife or people around him
Kian
Really confused about the set up. How was she able to force a marriage with someone who clearly didn’t want it, and had a matching position as her family? When her father even hater her, too. It appears her husband was even already happily engaged.
So she somehow convinced her father, who hated her, to broker a marriage with a man who also didn’t want to marry her, and break his pre-existing engagement?
stephanie
Omg i feel so bad for her like why did he chance on her after marriage??
akarie801
Why blaming her ? Blame the carriage men ! Its the carriage that broke !
amynamy
hang on!!! of course he slept with her in order to do his duty!!!! man, please be like some ML who have some dignity and self respect… Anyway, different time, different pov, glad i m in this era (even though things will be easier for woman in the future)
Kuroko
And my wish would be that when a new wind blows that trashy ML and all other trash shit die i wish to see her being happy with her child
𝐏𝐇𝐈𝐋𝐎𝐒𝐎𝐏𝐇𝐘
It’s so sad that she can’t meet a new ml cause she’s preggos UGH
aoerne
f you damn bulter
AismaMC
Disgusting husband!
Mazonia_Rain
Now that’s what I wanted to hear from the butler “a new wind might blow…” He’s lucky enough that she didn’t fired him too. I agree to her decision because if I did fired ‘All’ the servants in the castle including the butler no one would have serve my needs, so it’s good to not fired the butler but not trusting the butler as well is good choise.
Shamii
Please update fast I’m excited for the next update!😊
haru.bri101
THANK YOU FOR THE UODATE ❤️😭
𝐏𝐇𝐈𝐋𝐎𝐒𝐎𝐏𝐇𝐘
BRUH WHAT?? Y’ALL DIDN’T DO SH*T!!!!
𝐏𝐇𝐈𝐋𝐎𝐒𝐎𝐏𝐇𝐘
YOU GUYS ARE HEAVEN SENT!! THANKS FOR THE UPDATE!!!
yumi
cute baby
yeni_uwu
the “you weren’t here” 🙁 ; -;
yeni_uwu
Once again, a cute babyyyyy
Idk
NEXT CHAPP PLEASEEE :”
lilsy-san
I love this so much
Kuronight
I wanted someone else dont want him to be ML
Shamii
ONCE AGAIN?!!
PLEASE UPDATE MORE?!!!
OKEH I LIKE IT EVEN THOUGH THE ML STILL TRYING TO CHANGE BOHO
𝐏𝐇𝐈𝐋𝐎𝐒𝐎𝐏𝐇𝐘
CONGRAGU-FUCKING-LATIONS!!! THAT BABY IS SO CUTE OMGGGG🥳
yeni_uwu
the brother does care for her but that evil dad 🙁
jania
I’m glad the brother care about her, but the trashy dad
weirdoe
I WANNA SPOIL HER WITH HUGS I- 🤭😌💖
weirdoe
You go girl!
weirdoe
WOOOOOOO! I wonder if she’ll marry a different man~ Or woman 😏
weirdoe
MOVE DUM DUM, WE NEED A DIFFERENT ML!! 😤
Mazonia_Rain
Bruh!!!! You didn’t do Any Big sh1t!!!! You’re all terrible at handling big things jeez!!! You didn’t do any efforts!!!!
Shamii
I just want him to change a hate became love yeee!! 😫😍😂😂
Mazonia_Rain
Ah, this Dad is a MF in the beginning that I look at this dude.
Sheeio
Finally! A manhwa that starts with the female lead being pregnant and able to watch her child grow. I love this! Thnak you for this.
weirdoe
Let’s go run over that motherfucker 🤠✨
Katharsis
As long as you are happy mc, I’m happy too😭❤️
Alyawils19
I love the story big time!!!
BB blue
I need more.
Thanks for the update
Mazonia_Rain
Is that a dead bird??? Or someone??
Kuronight
What just happens at the end i want to know more 😖
Kian
Man, that’s quite bold of those people asking why the mother would attend her child’s naming ceremony, when she’s the duchess and clearly being backed by the duke despite whatever initial hostility they may have had.
dane123
i want more. is it a dead person.
MISSINGMARY
So cuteeee!
MISSINGMARY
just showed up and I already don’t like you, bitch
ManhwaQueen
How is she suddenly a cursed after that accident what a foolish father.. she was riding the same carriage as well as your wife and son they would’ve all died together and yet you blame your daughter for surviving just because she was physically unscathed.. ugh 😩 I can’ttttttt…
ManhwaQueen
The b*tch is on the radar 😒
Anzushi
Adorable!
syron13
Can we at the very least get some of his viewpoint so he isn’t such a bad future ML?
syron13
The Duke knew something was going to happen. I think there is a lot going on behind the scenes we aren’t privy to. Her dad could have helped set up this marriage without her knowledge just so that when she had a child it could be taken from her as revenge. The lady that raises her son in the past life is likely in on it all. She seems the manipulative type.
hehe
dope cctv
manga-lover
hahahahaaa cctv lol that was a good one
Kuronight
I still dont like that duke trash even if he changed himself now and is maybe reincarnated as well to the past like FL
I will get u
Wow😯
Mazonia_Rain
Why do I have a sus feeling that they are just using her since she now has a spirit…its just a gut feeling.
Mazonia_Rain
But nailed it, it’s a bird so I was right.
eliza24
the story is so good😶😶😶
Tsukibell88
Can we have side stories of her solving cases?!
lalaela
Omfg, can we change the ML – _-
prettydzai
LMAO Y’ALL SAYING ITS A CCTV HAJANSBXJSNNSNS
Serendipitous_Chaos
Looks like she misunderstood his actions in her previous life.
dane123
wow, that CCTV is amazing
Etherielle Laurel
I’m getting the distinct feeling the whole thing is a misunderstanding because she doesn’t talk and he doesn’t either
Etherielle Laurel
how in the world did this kind of father manage to love her until she was six years old?
lia_x
nice cctv lmao also more pls!!
Attakutti
Yesss duchess be confident!! You are the highest ranking after the royal family.
xmm
ngl lowkey annoyed that it took her putting out a huge fire for him to finally start caring.
Kuronight
He is still trash and i will not like him
yeni_uwu
not the spirits fighting and yesss reina go offfff
yeni_uwu
it’s always the red dress- like change it up a bitttt
Dorothy Gale
I feel like there are some pages missing….
Herurin
Dude why!?! This the dumbest dad ever…
Sheeio
Thanks for the update!!!
Sheeio
She really is perfect! Btw, Thanks for the update!
weirdoe
I am so dumb… I thought he said Doritos… but it was Pritos… I got excited for nothing 😔🤚
weirdoe
Fudge technology, we need Undine!
weirdoe
GO OFF GIRLIE!
weirdoe
Of course anything would suit her, she’s very pretty 😌✨
lalaela
Why did zi Bullsh*t husbando change? I rlly don’t want him as the ML ugh – _-
yeni_uwu
as u shouldddddd, reina!
Kia
he know everything from the first tl and he regrets it. he always loved reina but couldn’t show it because of reina’s father. reina’s father always wanted reina to suffer. i won’t spoil any more but just watch as the story unfolds.
Nobody
So you mean he came back from the past too or nah?
Kuronight
Soo we wont get any onfo why that trash changed so much like just done and done deal with it Can totally understand FLs disgust
Etherielle Laurel
Remember that comment he made before that made her think he hated her? I think it went something like “like father like daughter”? I wonder if he just meant that they didn’t know how to ask for something without threatening the person
lia_x
ok but that second prince is sus
i need help
the male lead is pretty unlikeable not gonna lie….
Irery
Hey, can you tell me from what manhwa your pfp is from?
Kuronight
Last chapter at the party she clearly showed disgust at him for his affection out of nowhere and now he ask her to go with him/stay near him when she clearly not to cross the line she would only perform her role as Duchess and i dont think a Duchess would go with her Husband to work
Attakutti
I think the husband isn’t bad.I can accept he is careless and a bit bad but not evil.
His pov if we think
He marries a woman who supposedly likes him(marry the one who loves you or the one you love) but then after marriage she is acting strange she doesn’t want to meet you….lives in outhouse(you don’t know servents are treating her badly or her mental health or how is she?..here it’s his fault) then your child is born and she doesn’t even want to touch the child due to her trauma…nanny may be taking care of the child but come on with mother in that condition you would want the child before your eyes(and some bish comes and spews venom saying it would be better for child to be in care of someone stable and proper and for mother to accept reality/maybe she doesn’t like her child coz he doesn’t look like her but him) the he takes the child away (here he did major bad he shouldn’t take a mother’s child away from her) she is heartbroken and withers away and dies.
yeni_uwu
^ Yea I agree but idk he should’ve thought about it more yk? Now, he’s jus reaping his carelessness, so let’s watch Reina heal 🙂
regressor666
I’ve already read through the spoilers and I know it’s the usual “this is all just a misunderstanding” trope boohoo but the ML still sucks. There were various circumstances that led to his cruel treatment of FL (agreement with FL’s dad to neglect her during marriage in exchange for his support of ML’s succession to dukedom, 1st TL there was a war and he didn’t know what was going on in the house, etc.)
BUT he still could’ve set the tone for his servants – they were awful to her. He could’ve told them to still treat her with respect even if he has to keep up the charade of ignoring her. Also, in the 1st TL he could’ve tried devise a plan to expose FL’s father after obtaining duke title and come clean to FL so at least she knows what’s going on but noooo. SO much inaction… At least tell her you idiot.
From what I know of the 2nd TL, he still didn’t do much about FL’s dad even knowing in advance he will try to bring the ex-fiancee in to kill FL. I don’t have the energy to care about his backstory and I’m glad they divorce. People, please stop victim blaming the FL. Her life was miserable enough as it is
Manwhua26189
@attakutti it isn’t like that. The duke (fl father) say that he would’ve make him the duke if he makes the fl suffer he first didn’t want to do that but eventually he did that. He told to his son that his mother isn’t his biological mother and that she killed his biological mother. That’s why the child was scared when he first saw her in her death bed. Ignored her and all. His son did kill his father when he became older but i really fell bad for the fl and her son. They all had an bad ending just cause he wanted to become the duke…
syron13
Looking like a mermaid would fit with er water spirit abilities.
BB blue
Hm, don’t know what to say….
Anyway, thanks for the update
Alyawils19
I need more chap to understand him more
Thank you!!!
Lara Davis
i already know about the cause his personality change from the novel………but yeah i still don’t like him
Serendipitous_Chaos
Im starting to think he may be catalyst behind her 2nd chance
angelus
Thank youu!!
MISSINGMARY
Thanks
We.go_weee
Ah yes, a well educated noble, who doesn’t have the need to think before doing an action which can cause a serious trauma for the children.
MISSINGMARY
I know that feeling
MISSINGMARY
I’m starting to feel like this guy remembers what happened too
MISSINGMARY
@Attakutii has a point. We know all that has happened to the FL but we didn’t see what the ML grasped out of their lives together… If you married a man that you just met, who runs away from you, don’t touch your child, doesn’t even live in the same house, would you perhaps thinks he likes you? I’m not a confrontational person so, even if its wrong, I would just let him be… And thats not right, but I didnt know any better
MISSINGMARY
He totally remembers or was the mains ’cause behind her returning to the past
Aeeam
This is intriguing. I cant seem to like her husband.
aleia
ah this piece of shit needs to go
aleia
she doesn’t look like she has a child omg aaaaaa
aleia
he’s prob the reason why she returned to the past and he remembers what she has been through
Attakutti
Damn fkin hell.This Duke here too!! To your own biological daughter how can you be so merciless you madman.no wonder you agreed my poor Raina I cry for her so much her beautiful childhood then her abused teenage years and then the isolation and deteriorating mental health why!!
Elle grew up but he is not happy either.in this life he should be happy.
Kuronight
Even after this chapter i still hate her Husband she deserves better and its kinda funny people said before he cared for FL but cannot show but all i see now is that he was selling her away with that trash father “never love,care” so he gets what support from this trash and if its true that he cared in his past life at some point we see FL’s disgust as he never showed so her husband only cared for money or help(support)
MNC
I hate the father. How can he be so shameless.
Kian
I read someone spoiled that “he couldn’t show love to her because of her father”, but they didn’t say he made a deal to advance his position in exchange for neglecting her! I thought it might have been something like the father holding something over him against his will, which would also explain why they married in the first place. Instead he was complicit out of greed. No redeeming aspect at all.
hiiiiiiiiiiii
so her husband and son are reborn or someting because el dont seem like a baby and in this chpt it make me feel like that bastard ( her husband) reborn .
aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhh just me and my thought .
Aria...
Ok guys here is the thing….. Our fl dad Is a bitch…. He (fl’s dad) brought black haired bitch…. He think that our fl has killed her wife whom he love very much… He told our ml to not to bother her… Means don’t do anything to fl…… Ml went for war. After giving elle to black haired bitch….. As a nanny….. After ml come back elle was already big enough and can not be separated from black haired bitch …… Emperor ls a real villian
BB blue
I won’t say anything about the ML.
If he can be better, and stop with that damn father. I will support him to be the ML.
Well of course, the most i want is Raina’s happiness.
So of her happy, i’m sure you guys will happy too
Sels
That man in hoodie was elle? Omyy. You better choose the right path now duke.
lalaela
This back story should be fckn worth it or I’ll curse this ML for my whole life.
Deinnn_
Ahhh elle is just so adorable
CairenSuller
So, the ml is unreliable because he needs support from such a trash man
xmm
sooo basically,,, if raina had never shown her powers aka proven her worth,, he wouldve continued ignoring her, and he’s only caring now cause the pros outweigh the cons.
Athanasia15
He doesn’t deserve her
Kuronight
I really hate him even with more info even nothing what he did in her past life where right choices or good reason and now he is different? Why can he protect her now?
Etherielle Laurel
Huh. Okay, so he didn’t really care about her before as more than just a part of the deal with her father, but then started feeling guilt when her son locked her in their manor with the spirits replaying her life there. Sooooo. He DID NOT love her before, but things have changed and he’s starting to become fond of her, at the very least.
Attakutti
I really hate the Duke he made both his own daughter and ml’s life hell and Elle’s life too.That kind of obsessive love isn’t good if you are gonna blame your own children afterwards and go as far to destroy there life.like wtf man for the child parents do everything to ensure there child’s happiness.
Etherielle Laurel
Calm down. He DIDN’T like her in the beginning, just kind of felt like they were in the same situation. He DIDN’T want to abuse or torment her, he was trapped into that by her father and didn’t make any effort to reach out to her. NO, I don’t think he’s a great guy, and she deserved better. But it’s not like he set out to destroy her life like her dad did.
Rael
Not defending him or anything. But maybe the ml accepted the conditions so that he could be at a better position and then the fl wouldn’t be in as much harm as before when she lived with her father. Tho, I think that ml should have treated her better after becoming the Duke tho
Dove W.
I still fucking hate him
Amelia
Honestly , i hate the male lead. Just because his father-in-law said she is cursed and dont give her love otherwise he wont get support for succession annoyes me. Now he apoligizes and says everything is his fault when his son punishes him is even more frustrating. I hope u die. You dont deserve forgiveness cuz the one to forgive is already dead hating you. 🤬🤬
Dove W.
Yea I take back what I said-
I don’t hate u ml
I hate the father bastard
Zeno
Btw. What’s with her childhood friend?
lalaela
U-huh, still hate him.
Aeeam
So the her husband reincarnated too?
Athanasia15
I don’t want to forgive ml for hurting the fl but somehow my eyes are filled with tears 😢 😭
BB blue
I will support the ML.
Cause this time, he didn’t repeat his mistake.
But if there’s the SML, i will think twice about it😂
Kim Yoo
Come on guys, it wasn’t the ML’s fault that he had to treat the FL like that…he was forced by her father to do so cause if he didn’t then the father would kill her as he said ‘the child will die’, dang it guys, the father planted people in the ml’s mansion-ready to kill the FL if the father sent word…he was trying to protect her by obeying Fl’s fathers’ demands. The concubine as well was part of the father’s plan…the real culprit is FL’s father…
Yoon Kim
@ Manwhua26189 the ML did think it was a good offer at first but the duke(FL father) threatened the ML of the FL’s life and by killing his people by joining hands with the first prince..thats why the ML first rejected FL father the first time cause it was an abrupt demand to marry someone and neglect them, he didn’t accept it because he wanted to be a duke-he accepted it to protect his men and the Fl.
Mazonia_Rain
I forgive the ML, As they say, “Forgive those who are aware of their own sins and wants to change themselves to be better”
At least he knows it is wrong for him to act that way, he even doesn’t want to do that in the first place, he was just been disadvantage by the scum to take over his and her life like some puppet.
Yk2angelic
BROOO I FUCKING HATE HIIIMM 😡😡 HE MESSED UP AND EVEN IF HE IS TRYING TO FIX HIS MISTAKES, ITS NOT GOING TO WORK CAUSE HE SHOULD’VE NEVER DONE IT IN THE FIRST PLACE. ALSO SHE WAS DEPRESSED AND HE MADE IT WORSE BY MAKING HER SUFFER. 🤬
Bossa nova-chan
PLS SEND US A NEW ML!!!
Bossa nova-chan
@Mazonia_Rain
I agree with u 🙂
CairenSuller
How boring… Next chapter please.. Idc about his past
meistherealdeal
พ่อเหี้ยมากไอเหี้ย
meistherealdeal
เห้อ ปวดกบาล
ManhwaQueen
Her father is a rotten a-hole!! Grrrrr! He pisses me off!! Ughh.. (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻
MoonmistLuna
Ikr
Meij98
At least you know…..
Athanasia15
Update more quickly
Athanasia15
This is what you call regret
Athanasia15
At least you realize now
Secondmaleleadlove
I still hate him
Vhalcy
Sorry but, I can forget what you have done
mags1225
Could he possibly remember what he did in her previous life?
Katevai
Its a good thing he knows I mean….
Mininemesis
I pity the both of them, the real evil is her father and all the evil people he put besides them. They had no chance of being happy and surviving that first timeline….
Shillion the Wise
Is nobody even going to comment on the fact that she keeps risking not her own life but the life of her unborn child to save strangers? She was told it was dangerous for the child to use powers but she used them multiple times anyway, she was told that it was dangerous for the child to form a contract but she formed one anyway. I realize that in actuality there will be no consequences since this is a work of fiction but that doesn’t change the fact that she risked her own child’s life multiple times… she is kind of a terribly irresponsible mother for risking the child’s safety that many times to save some rando people.
Bitch the hell ya saying
at least he know is faults. and also the fuck is wrong with her father like she is his real blood.
elydee11
Hmmmm
Haiko
Interesting how both of them were reincarnated and that it came from the ML this time. However, I still have difficulties to forgive him. I understand his circumstances and it looks like the emperor isn’t reliable either. As a man with no power as that time, going against FL father was like walking to your death. However, did he really have to neglect her this much ? Idk, I have mixed feelings about this. I don’t hate him but she suffered so much…. But in any cases, the story is super interesting and I like all this dilemma.
12345lina
Whoah he knew that the duchess also returned, nice
༼ಢ_ಢ༽
graaaahhhhh i want more! dont be like this! i want a mountain of chapters! ( ಥ _ ಥ )
im currently studying korean language and once i mastered it i will translate some manhwas!
MNC
OMG. I WILL DIE WITH THIS EPISODE
Hush
Yeah, what would you do??? Now that you know that you’re not the only one who remembers the past (or should i say the future) how would you atone for it?!
xmm
DAMN. i wasnt expecting this. Makes the redemption arc more deserving ig
hehe
whoaa this is new
Lara Davis
Still don’t like him lol
R. I. P that puy ayee
My eyes are filled with tears this is low-key sad
_lucia
Omg!! This is so unexpected i think its because of ell cutie little angel…
Attakutti
Holy!! So it’s the Duke whose wish is come back in time!!and he even knows somewhat that she is also from past!!what if Elle knows too????
meistherealdeal
รู้ตัวก็ดีแล้ว
Kuronight
Even after all this i dont like ML how he did thing just to get in his second life touchy i still remember at that ball where FL looked so disgusted at the tough he would love her
weirdoe
can the father just like… 凸(>皿<)凸
Sophie
Both the knights and the nobles are trash. How could they think and say those bad things to Reina? I hope they get what they deserved.
Melissa<3Nine
I agree with Haiko I mean he doesn’t have to neglect her this much he could have shown affection or care sometimes in between surely that wouldn’t be known to fl father and fl will have at least an inkling of thought that maybe ml held some affection for her
BB blue
This story is such a…
Ugh, i can’t say it
BRUH
Ohhhhhhhh i understand now
Meij98
“Have you finally decided to be human?” – best line I’ve read this year
Danboozle
This story makes me wanna hate him but looking at his point of view this following chapters just makes me want to wish both of them happiness… the real villain that Mother effin father if it weren’t for him, IT WAS ALL BECAUSE OF GIM TO BEGIN WITH!
Attakutti
Aww duke don’t worry anymore just confess Everything so you both can do best with new beginning.
And i hate MC’s father so much! For some reason I think that fire was also caused by him.damn even the devil is kind to its own kid.
teaaaluv
can the father and the b1tch d1e already i just want the three of them to be a happy family just ughhhh
Cursen
“I like you now”…. Bullshit, he was an asshole before now he is just a sorry asshole. Being sorry won’t wash away your sin.
CairenSuller
Stuuuuuppppidddd
Baka Yuii
I can’t like him, but I don’t hate him either
Illigurl
I mean I understand he was a horrible horrible husband and father in his past life but atleast he understood his mistake n really wants to improve….if Reina can get a second chance can’t he….?
Mimika
🇹🇭👍
Mimika
Ohhh shiiiit he messed up real big time
Reki
umm no, just no
Kuronight
Still thinking she deserves mich more and better
Lazylife
Yeahhh you like her now that she’s is strong and doesn’t need you ! A trash is a trash… you had to be there when she needed it not now argh this is just bullshit that will not make me like him he is just pathetic he didn’t give a shit back then so now don’t crawl to her !!!
liliana
oh my goddddd
where is the author painter editor I wanna really kiss those artistv hands and brain of yours
ufffmy hearteu
dora
what i like about this story is every character realized what they do wrong… even the duchess as a victim know what she do wrong and did a better job now so that she can’t became an easy victim.. the duke too.. wish they become a lovey dovey couple in this life
Alyawils19
How about both of you talk to each other heart to heart pls
Lila4realsss
Holy fuck
InnerDesperation
Whether I want him to be forgiven or not won’t affect this story’s trajectory of him being forgiven in the end. Honestly, it would have been better if he didn’t remember the previous timeline. I just think that it sucks that the FL had to wait for a second chance for the ML to make things right. Rather, ML should be asking himself if he deserves forgiveness instead of expecting that he’ll obtain forgiveness just because he’ll treat her differently this time around.
Anyway, the father is a complete (excuse my language) asshat, but the (Grand?) Duke is just as much as an asshat for agreeing to his plans. I believe that there is 100% no reason to treat people like crap when they had done nothing to deserve it. He even knew about her circumstances, too. Haiz… poor past El, good on you for locking up your cheap, crappy father and destroying that stupid empire.
AetherinatisDyAsh
I know all of you are serious but i saw a Yuri manhwa saying what the fuck(I forgot the name)
Etherielle Laurel
it just took him what, 60 years?
Newbana
DFAQ!! what kind of deals is that!!
glad he suffered like that and glad that he is trying to fix it now
Lovely
This story make me cry 😳😳
Ahensherline San
I want him to repent his whole life for his doings,well I guess it not only her who has reincarnated but him and his son as well , that’s why I guess elle is able to understand his surroundings, everyone got a rebirth through regrets, every character even her, well, all I want is her father to suffer from nightmares and anxiety, doesn’t matter if he has past memories or whether he repent for it, but he has to suffer from those endless suffocation which she has gone through…… 💨
Ahensherline San
Just repent yourself and protect both your wife and your son……
yumi
I hate duke but at the same time you want to change so I will forgive you
Etherielle Laurel
Hm, has Elle come back in time too? I mean, he acts more like a normal baby than other reborn characters in manhwas, but it could just be he wanted to enjoy his time with his mother.
anna beraia
Etherielle Laurel that’s exactly what i was thinking too!
Raindship
So that’s explained his attitude to the fl,, and his also reincarnate
Raindship
Wow too much drama but this chapter explains everything I’m starting to like it
Isimpfor2Dpeople
if thats the case then everyone most have came back.
zpi16804
Why would they bring a baby to a banquet party like that?
zpi16804
Don’t put a pillow in a crib with a baby, it can suffocate the baby.
outsider
wow, i cried lol
I want to be reincarnated
Ughhh, it’s such a sad story, but I’M glad that he realized the wrong things that he have done.
Jellyjelly
I hate this blonde guy
supahmanhwaaddict
bruh? why are you saying she’s cursed? there’s no substancial evidence. the horse could’ve been maltamed, the carriage could’ve been tampered with.
megan
i understand a lot now, so he went back too im guessing
megan
i want to hate him but i cant cauz part of me understands. i want the three of them to be happy in this life.
megan
@etherielle laurel , i think it would be so much better if he’d come back too and is just enjoying spending time with his mum, things he missed in his past life!
meistherealdeal
วดฟ
please take that uncle away from my sight thank you
ellie_king
same same please take white haired creepy guy, thanks in advance
Etherielle Laurel
Huh. So this is how those ridiculous creeps on throwns decide to pit their children against each other for the heir position: they’re bored. Someone needs to take another look at imperial education methods
BB blue
Ah, that white uncle just spoke nonsense.
Such a ridiculous emperor.
How can they have that kind of emperor.
Anyway, why must cliffhanger.
Waiting for the next chapters.
Thank you.
laysia
is it just me or i still want her to leave her husband
Kuronight
I feel like trash is slapped at me from right to left lol first we need to Accept her Husband and i still dont fully like him and then more and more trash characters pop up like that king now…
ఠࡇఠ
haaaaaaaaist…. another cliff.
BlackPhoenix
He does try to help behind the scenes and is threatened. Not saying I forgive him but it is fine if he basically become’s FL’s slave. that shud make up for it.
Bianca
Now I get why she fell for him………. But he’s still a jerk. A douchebag-
kasjein
i dont think she loves him but i think she wont leave the ml but idk this isnt a spoiler btw
Conf
The story line is a bit confusing to me. Like the FL’s feeling.
So Angry
I feel sorry for Elle and I hate Fl’s dad so much. He should be killed by Elle to. Damn you, son of a bitch.
Pissed me off
I hate FL’s dad so bad. You piece of shit. And you you damn ML., but if you don’t follow that piece of shit someone will die, but I still kinda hate you. I wanna hate you a little bit less than this but I can’t. You hurt our FL and her son too much.
Balkys
Thanks for the update!
Roco
Just fire them all since youre in charge of the estate
Kuronight
I mean just get rid of them
Lazylife
After all she has done so far those servants dare to disrespect the duchess ?? Fire them
moonlunar
thx for the update
pinkstone54
Not a huge fan of the art style and am not really hooked yet. I will give it a few more chapters before I drop it.
pinkstone54
Are the servants idiots? She’s carrying the heir and they’re trying to make her sick?
BB blue
I would like to see her fire all of them
Your soulmate
Agree just fire them all, EASYYY~
shar
please take that grandpa away, i would greatly appreciate it
anna beraia
Get rid of those bastards and hire people who are actually trust worthy, I mean, you are in charge of the estate right?
I'm_your_normal_weeb
Too cute… ugh this why I should stop reading manhwas with cute babies/children my nose is bleeding
I'm_your_normal_weeb
That thing in her forehead and her hair reminds me of sakura
I'm_your_normal_weeb
If you want I’ll k*ll them all got you 😉
I'm_your_normal_weeb
For*
boobee666
milf
robin p
Mk i guess maybe you can be forgiven by her 🤷♀️
cutewizard1234
Yas queennnnnn 😎
Ametrine
I don’t know why her father blamed her? What did she do? It was an accident …Shouldn’t he be grateful that he still had one child that survived? Stupid man.
Ametrine
At least the children survived*
Ametrine
Wow her husband is a bastard….How can someone rip away a mother and child??? What the hell?
Ametrine
What a trash ML….
Ametrine
Disgusting servants…They don’t know their place, they deserved to all be fired. How cruel ….to feed a pregnant woman rotten fruit??? Unbelievable….That made me so angry. And that butler…What? A new wind might blow? I hope the wind blows him off a cliff if he doesn’t do his job properly.
Ametrine
Urh these people…Selfish…
Ametrine
Waiting for the whole background to be revealed as to why this ML bastard changed.
Ametrine
Hmm That’s still not a good reason….Still don’t like the Duke…the father is freaking crazy….He blames her for the death of his wife like what? Does that even make sense? can;t get over how stupid he is.
Ametrine
He could have still loved and shown her affection behind closed doors and explained to her what happened. He messed up big time, she died after living a hellish life and his son became crazy.
Ametrine
Ah I cried when she staring at the wall…..I was also listening to piano music too…Urhhh my heart!!! You can’t just rip apart a mother who loves her child…
Ametrine
Took him a second try at life (literally) to figure that out…I mean he did a lot of wrong in the past even though the father was the one to blame he should have just stood up to him! She’s married now so the father has no say….Disgusting sadistic father. I want a good downfall for him.
Ametrine
Crazy people are always around…
Ametrine
Not sure why they have so many disgusting servants….How did they ever get the job?
kweenbwii
Does any of you encounter a manhua which the mc has awoken the king of elf?
Alyawils19
Right might as well use him lol
Sofia
The dad is so childish.She was a child,a literal CHILD when that accident happened,children gets scared more rather than being rational.It wasn’t her fault that the carriage swerved or the mother died trying to save her brother,the mother willingly sacrificed her life because the mother knew getting out of a carriage while it was still running was dangerous.And cursed? If she’s cursed then doesn’t that mean you are too? She’s your DAUGHTER,and she has HALF YOUR BLOOD.
Sometimes manhwa dad’s are dumb af and childish.
Sofia
Man sometimes people are shits.Of course she’s going to be there,she’s the mother.
Sofia
Wow, this isn’t the first time I hate an FL’s dad but childish much?.Why the heck is the dad being so f—-ing ridiculously childish? ‘never love that child’ ‘ignore her’,.Man dude, yes I understand you’re wife died but for f—‘s sake get a therapist.
Sofia
Huh…well we all now knew who was the cause of the problem at the very start,the Dad.The very shitty dad,the insanely-childish-dad,the you’re-the-cause-of-your-mother’s-death-dad,the dad who just can’t seem to forgive his child because IT WAS PROBABLY THE DRIVER”S FAULT AND THE CARRIAGE BUT SURE I’LL BLAME MY CHILD BECAUSE DAUGHTER+INSIDE CARRIAGE+WHO WAS HOLDING ON FOR DEAR LIFE=CAUSE OF WIFE”S DEATH.
Sometimes what on earth is going on with some manhwa dad’s heads? Sure I’ll blame my daughter,who was just a child at that time,for their mother’s death.
Sofia
Shoot,he may have been an ass but this pov is successfully making me rethink my feelings.I pity the both of them.
For FL to have such a crappy dad (Your wife is embarrassed to have you as a husband) and ML to somehow be related to the crappy dad.
Sofia
Why is it that every father in this manhwa is either deranged or weird?
BB blue
Hmmm, i will remain silence for now.
I still can’t forgive him for right now.
Maybe a little longer, he can change my mind
Rainbowkookie
Wait is that the mother of the Ml?
Clareysa
I know the present duke was rude to the girl who has pink hair in the 1st life-sorry forgot the nameಥ_ಥ. his wife, i mean-, I want they ended up together even they have to divorce first, cause the duke is begin to having an affection and love to her in his 2nd life. I just want them to be happy ಠ◡ಠ
ashen
I didn’t understand someone explain it to meeeeeeeeeee.
Attakutti
It’s the current ml’s mother poor lady and Duke was probably not loved either.
Kuronight
So he prepared some toy still not far enough for what he had done
Roco
even the toys he brought Elle are dangerous, I guess he kinda tried?
evil hoe
Is it really that you like him sir? Or are you just driven and blinded by your guilt? Sorry mofo but you ain’t going to receive forgiveness that easy
Torong7
Others be like:”i like you now” bullshit brohe’s an asshole in his past life and now he’s apologizing to her?
Me: Btches do you all fckin even know what CHANGE is? putangina. He knows what he is doing! What he did in the past is horrible but he was reincarnated and did the right thing not the BAD thing. Idiot
Torong7
I’m done with yall.yung mga nasa comment mga obob kaya di humahaba relasyon niyo ng jowa mo e di kasi kayo nagpapatawad. Jusko mga utak at puso niyo tol ayus ayusin. Niyo nga
Torong7
Is it just me that i want to punch those bullshit peoples telling to leave her husband and find the new ml and have a good life? Yall… The ml is already guilty. Mga putangina sarap pagsasampalin ng mga nasa comments section
Alyawils19
Now we’re talking
Thalyssra
Her dad is nuts
I'm_a_weirdoe_fan
Men why the cliffhanger?
Thalyssra
I think the husband may have memories of their past life, that would explain why he changed so much, like he’s trying to compensate or something.
Thalyssra
I KNEW IT, I KNEW HE ALSO RETURNED! HUMPF!
Right your wrongs so I can hate you less.
Lolol
Her relatives are absolutely terrible, putting all the blame on her just because she’s the only one that survive? She may be not injured or dead at that time but please experiencing something that traumatic especially when it has to do with someone important to you would be a big impact to you. She can even barely sleep without taking medicines or sleeping pills, imagine being relieved that you can finally sleep then all you can dream of was the traumatic past.
You can’t call yourself a father in this kind of situation, never.
Lolol
WHAT A BASTARD WHY WOULD YOU GIVE HER OWN CHILD TO A BITCH
Im(not)asimp
Oof the rejection
Im(not)asimp
I think his majesty has taking a liking in or reina
Im(not)asimp
I also think that
Im(not)asimp
CLIFF HANGER
Im(not)asimp
Gurl youre a bad a*s
Im(not)asimp
Oof thats messed up
Im(not)asimp
Oh no poor edhar
Lolol
lives are lives YOU CAN’T JUST NOT HELP THEM JUST BECAUSE YOU’RE A DAMN NOBLE, LISTEN HERE YOU LITTLE SHIT IN THIS SITUATION NOW IS NOT THE TIME TO BE SELFISH AND HELP PEOPLE BASED ON THEIR RANKS DON’T BE GODDAMN BIASED YOU BASTARDS
Lolol
Okay I forgive you, I guess you deserve to be the ml
Lolol
Blackjack?? Ain’t that one kpop group
✨BTS THE BEST ✨
Dw Reina! You’ve done nothing wrong! You can do it! 💕✨
Lilinight
Link: https://discord.gg/anXrmusm96
A manhwa server
●Manhwa/Manga recommendations
●SFW
●Active with over 4k members
●Fun Bots
●They rarely tag everyone
●Giveaways
●Friendly staff and members
Morning
lia_x
@Lolol honey i think that’s blackpink
Lya K
there was something wrong with the carriage incident… father has a hand on it… sus… really sus….
Lya K
thought so…. her father… really…
Lya K
hmm…. idk…. I can’t deny the fact that he liked her but it was also his fault that she was hurt… so idk anymore if I should ship him with her….. *hella confused abt if I should ship or not ship*
Lya K
ugh! this is soooo frustrating! idk anything anymore….. urgh!
nekoyukichan
Reina reminds me of reiner from aot everytime 😭✋
Reki
not reiner 😭✋
Ava_2
Pls- reiner😭🖐🏻
lanarii
bullshit
lanarii
why r the fathers sooooo LSBDKSHDJSSJDH PERMISSION TO PUNCH THEM PLEASE?
Aya Mahmood
So little
Ametrine
Urh it’s always like this…noble ladies that have nothing to do all day and they just gossip about other people.
Lilinight
https://discord.gg/anXrmusm96
A manhwa server
●Manhwa/Manga recommendations
●SFW
●Active with over 5k members
●Fun Bots
● They rarely tag everyone
●Giveaways
Kiyyqq
God I wanna slap all those nobler ladies up and that empress is so annoying
Alinuska
It’s just a ball calm down, she’s still more powerful than y’all
Roco
what’s the point of being so mean to a duchess, like she can’t ruin all the families beneath her if she really wanted to ?? sometimes these other noble ladies are so dumb
BakemonoRis
Wow over dramatic dad…maybe he was the one who caused that accident….
BakemonoRis
What is wrong with that guy!! Her brother needs to succeed as the head of the fam. Time meow
BakemonoRis
Heh. Well why did he treat her so coldly before !! Why did he even say those kind words in the beginning in the first place and just abandon her n all !
BakemonoRis
Oh?? What was that expression in the end Duke…
BakemonoRis
OMG AND THE TRUTH COMES OUT!!!
BakemonoRis
Whoa
BakemonoRis
Oh shizz okay !!!!
BakemonoRis
What the fudge. Why the servants thinking like they Matter
BakemonoRis
So fudged
BakemonoRis
Does her being a dutchess now not mean squat, peasants! Fudge her future. Look at who she is married to now bruh.yall need ur heads to roll!!!
Tia23
First of all, she is a duke’s daughter (though I hate it) and she also married a Duke and became Duchess
What make them think that she can’t squash them like ants 🤷♀️
nekoyukichan
aww 🙁
Jes
🥺🥺🥺I wish for your both happiness!!!
kanao_tsyuri
awwwwww so cute
kanao_tsyuri
I forgive you……………….for now
jojobery
i just wanna punch the man that said “sHe CAn’T dO aNtHInG ‘cAuSe ShE’s A wOmAn”
jojobery
her dad looks like he is responsible for her mother death
Midnight
I feel like the ml went back in time too..? There are two scenes that support my theory, first scene was when he slammed the doors open when Reina, our fl, was hesitating to hold Elle, he shows up and takes elle but he places elle on top of reina, as if he was saying that it was okay. The second scene was in this chapter, reina was also hesitating to acknowledge elle’s life to begin but the ml held her hand and acknowledged the beginning of his son’s life and reina followed. This is just a theory.
Midnight
Like i said before, My theory still stands, The duke probably went back in time too to fix his mistakes.
AFL
Oh wow so by the end everything was the trash dad’s fault!!
AFL
Omg because of his cowardness he caused such problems for her 🙄 jeez I just want her to get a divorce and live a happy life with her son. Poor Ell also was in pain because of dumb ass daddy and trash grandpa
AFL
Let their asses look for a new job then if they don’t understand who is the boss
Froggy_frog
He better fox what he fucked up in his previous life…. 𝐑𝐞𝐚𝐝 𝗺𝗼𝐫𝐞
Froggy_frog
I meant fix
Froggy_frog
I’m just trying to enjoy the interesting comments not essay so could you please write shorter comments thanks
Froggy_frog
Yeah me too I think the same @Im(not)asimp
Miiyaa
His face in that closeup face pic: 👁 | 👁
pipipipipi
just please die u mfs
pipipipipi
wtf☠️
pipipipipi
tangina talaga
Moon Shine
For crying out loud… All humans make mistakes. It is inevitable. Even you people in the comments have made many mistakes. That is the nature of a human being. It doesn’t matter how much of a bad person they are or how many mistakes they’ve made. Even a murderer deserves a second chance. But most of these people don’t realise the mistakes they’ve made and don’t try to change.
At least this duke (The FL’s husband) has realised his many mistakes and has been offered a second chance. At least he is trying to change and become both a better husband and a better father. You’ve seen the trauma that he has from his past life. It’s a little like the FL’s, so don’t ridicule him for that. He, too, is suffering. Guilt is a heavy burden and that can damage anyone’s mental health.
At least acknowledge that he is trying his best to change. I’m not meaning to be rude, but it doesn’t matter whether you forgive him or not. It is the FL’s decision, and if second chances seem wimpy or disgusting to you, then maybe this manhwa isn’t for you. But these types of manhwa’s are clearly trying to tell us that everyone deserves a second chance if they’ve realised their mistakes. It honestly makes my heart ache that you people are criticising him so harshly. You wouldn’t be saying this if you were in his shoes, now would you?
I’m not saying that you should just let his actions in their past life slide, but he is suffering too. Don’t you think you should give them a second chance, one that he is desperate in earning? I thin k you should at least admit he is changing for the better. Let me leave you this inspiring quote, since you all need to see that forgiveness actually exists.
“The weak can never forgive. Forgiveness is an attribute of the strong.”
And keep in mind that I’m not trying to fight you or start unnecessary drama. I merely want you to acknowledge that he is doing his best to change. I’m kind of getting tired of seeing people who think that forgiveness shouldn’t be given to those who realise their mistakes, like the “Trashy ML’s”. Thank you for taking the time to read my comment 😁
kaorii
update pleaseee!!!!!! im beging ya’lll😭😭😭😭😭😭
Raa chii
This make me want baby without husband
Raachii
Aww pretty mum
Taa Taa
Everything reborn but her trash father not. I love these plot twist.
Taa Taa
Oh I know. The past was so hurt
Taa Taa
Return to their past I wanna cry , everything bcuz of her f*ck stupid crazy dad.
Jeezzz
Our elle the true heroes here
TaTo
Please upload more,I can’t wait
Hehehehe
What if the kid came back too since it said that he follows your voice when you say his name? although it could just be a natural response
nicoleee
ᜆᜆᜌ᜔ ᜈᜋᜈ᜔ ᜉᜎ ᜀᜅ᜔ ᜋᜌ᜔ ᜉᜃᜈ 😠
Abyss101
the art is good and the spirit gosh its cute.
Abyss101
well maybe the dad is suffering from depression or something…but even so i feel bad for her
Abyss101
so did she go ask her father for marriage? or did he propose to her?
Abyss101
umm like his husband just totally separated them? like he should have waited kept a nanny for taking care of the child why the separate building altogether?
Abyss101
is it just me or its rushed up a lot without proper explaination
Abyss101
well atleast the brother is sane
Abyss101
i like her dress
Abyss101
what the actual fuck??? that father i just thought he was too depressed and thus neglected blamed and abused her but this???? and that idiot he actually listen as well
Abyss101
so those guys did turn back time now….i get it and its messed up but i hope they reconsile
Abyss101
well since both of them returned back to the past maybe they could talk it out or something
Pao_15
I LOVE HER
Pao_15
I LOVE HER, SHE’S SO BADASS
Abyss101
i think elle came back too…so was it his spirit magic that turned back time or something? like its good whatever it is
Abyss101
well i kinda pity his husband now…i hope they get everything cleared soon
Abyss101
wel atleast he is trying to make an effort
Tia23
It’s been so long guys
Kanao_Tsuyuri
Now I kinda ship them
Noir
its been 84 years, 5 months and 13 days….
Bookworm3400
So far we know: Reina is in the past after dying, probably of grief or something; Edhart is in the past from an unknown point (probably his death) after Reina died; and Elle got revenge for his mom by locking up his dad in the same place she was isolated. So, my question is….
Did Elle come back in time too? That would be really cool, but IDK if that would happen.
vickykrimixx
Please time skip K want to see Elle to grow up😄
vickykrimixx
I*
Jden
FINALLY TALKING AND COMMUNICATING!1!!!
Alphexa
Yeah blame her for the carriage inspector not making sure the wheels and latch were secured and that the coach driver couldn’t steer properly.
clairederiver
I’m 99% confident the duke also traveled back like her
kryiscool
no but like i dont understand why he turned so cold towards her cus in the past when they first met he was kind and considerate so??? why was he so cold when they finally got married??
xohdkrwu
I swear the scanlaters or auther forgot abt this or smth
Thisisamisunderstanding
In Hindi “Ma” directly translates to mom to that accurate too….in a way.
Kuronight
Still dont like him i dont care that he is now blushing all over her and all that bullshit i see that he is trying but not enough for what he did to her
CapricornChild
@UnknownLaury Yeah? She’s having post partum depression and she’s the one to be blamed just cause she can’t touch her child? Uhmmm… 🤷🏻♀️
ariana giyu
SUCH A BULLSH-
Berryholic
Yeah plz be stronger for ur child
Berryholic
Still can’t forgive the duke
Potato
I huv waited this for a very long years n i got old n died peacefully but i woke up frm my death when i saw it was uptaded.
Berryholic
Love her face “wth does he want with me” lol
Crys
That just says everything about his personality A FUC-TARD
Berryholic
Don’t forgive him yet
Berryholic
glad to see Her life this time is brighter
Berryholic
Hmmm he really unlikable character
Berryholic
U don’t deserve her duke
Berryholic
Still unforgivable what he did till she died
Keiji
When I saw the crown the only thing I thought was Mr thick neck bitch
Anonymous
Omg yes finally😭 Elle and the spirit is as cute as always 😌 and I missed you our FL.
Keiji
why yall bringing Reiner into this 😭✋
Ametrine
Oh it’s been a while….
kryiscool
woow i cried a little
AlexTheCrystal
Ah yes only your wife can call you your name but you call her wife
Gojo
He’s forgiven since he’s the one who turn back time.
donuts is love
@Bookworm3400 when did the part of elle get revenge for his mom happen ?
Celeste
She looks like a goddess
Etherielle Laurel
I wonder if Elle was the one who reversed time. Last time, we knew about his powers, but Reina didn’t discover hers and the duke isn’t mentioned as having any himself. Plus, it went back to right around when she found out she was pregnant, so it would still be within his life. So, if he’s the one who reversed time, would he remember?
AFL
As I remember there were some panels before in former chapters about how duke is regretting his past behavior towards his wife considering how their son got a revenge on him when he grew up coz of his dead mom. So duke remembers the past as well and is trying to fix the problems and that is why he cares so much about her and their son now right?
Sips ✨🍵✨ Aggressively
…..So no one saw the name Ifrit?
Sips ✨🍵✨ Aggressively
I’m busting out my combs!!! Time to fix his hair!!
The bitch
The bitch has showed up
PhantomReader
A Bitch has appeared
Rose
Y r the uptades so late !!??
I guess author u r very busy😔
^_^Just_commenting_here_and_there^_^
My one of my friends recommended this to me…
Now I won’t tease them as much as I did
^_^Just~commenting~here~and~there^_^
And the reward for the most stupidest ass father goes to…
This asshole!
^_^Just~commenting~here~and~there^_^
And the reward for the most stupidest ass father goes to…
This asshole!🎊
^_^Just~commenting~here~and~there^_^
And I just finished reading Actually I was the real one😭
Brianna Finch
To people saying that Elle went back in time, there is no way, because he wouldn’t have been so cute and loving with his father. Smiling and holding his finger and stuff.
Overly obessed manhwa reader
BRUH WHAT????
THAT’S JUST BULLSHIT!
YOU AIN’T DONE ANYTHING!!
DO YOU THINK WERE STUPID OR SOMETHING?!
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Medieval version of a cctv😂
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Where the heck is the second ml? We still need to change him.
I’m sorry but he is still trashy like trashta
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Any thing will go well with her🥰
•Foodie obsessed with this•
PERIODT QUEEN!👑😤
•Foodie obsessed with this•
No one:
Me waiting for the big and sad backstory of that “husband”: 👁👄👁
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Someone pls get me the second ml stat! Cause I need to change the husband with the second ml before my blood pressure rises to high.
I mean bruh
He was always so damn cold but now…
He acting as though he’s in love with her or something
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Bitch pls don’t tell me this is gonna be like “Actually, I was the real one”.
Keira’s father turned back time for his daughter and kinda changes.
But in this manhwa it’s the shitty ass husband.
Great.😒
•Foodie obsessed with this•
So…
The ml was innocent along
But good thing I sharpened my knife
Cause instead of the ml
I’ll kill that bastard of a “FAtheR” instead!
😈🔪
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Damn.
That’s just harsh😔
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Ask for forgiveness
That’s the thing you have to do
And be more nicer and kinder and more approachable to her.
•Foodie obsessed with this•
And the best manhwa quote goes to…
The knight that said “Have you finally decided to become human?”
It now lives rent free in my head😌
•Foodie obsessed with this•
@Brianna Finch.
But if you read WMMAP then it can work.
Athy pretended to be sweet and innocent to survive but later realises Claude is actually a nice father but just broken.
The same can go for Elle.
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Take that ugly ass grandpa out of my sight before I gorge my eyes out.🤢🤮
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Just fire them
And if that’s not enough then I’ll just assassinate them for you for free
•Foodie obsessed with this•
@Bakemonoris. Facts!
•Foodie obsessed with this•
@Lolol. I think you mean Blackpink.
I’m kinda offended by you but only a tiny bit since I’m a very passionate Blanpink fan/Blink.
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Nooo!
Why ya’ll bringing Reiner into this?!😭🤚🏽
•Foodie obsessed with this•
Their audacity and boldness levels are up the roof but their positions in nobility can be as low as peasants.
•Foodie obsessed with this•
@Etherielle Laurel. Most likely due to him being a very powerful spiritualist.
Mmm
I still hate that man
Yooom
I still hate that trash
Tolger
He’s a jerk for agreeing with that deal and being so selfish i still hate him
Lolol
I’m sorry but it’s just too late you’ve hurt her so much
Maple my7h
I’m glad he wasn’t shit after all
Maple my7h
Bro,this is getting better because both of them wanted to go back because they both have regret,but since both of them reamber the pass tis means it will be hard (but now they look like they are getting better)
Gojo
This taking so long.
Kakali
Gosh
kreidepri
Manga server
New with little people
Recommendations and making friends!!
https://discord.gg/DXjCnxtNAB
Allysha
Sakura is that you ⊂((・▽・))⊃
Isekai
Duke this is for you 凸( •̀_•́ )凸
•Can’t stop and won’t stop reading•
Ikr
Husna
Bro you need to try harder i still don’t like u
Osonudista
I don’t understand anything 😆
Lysithea
^ I’d like to think so too. *-*
Lysithea
Wiggly… lol xD
kash
but your husband traveled too
Lysithea
Jeez, this story has all kind of sneaky demons everywhere, even in the past. I assumed there will be more in the future. May FL find happiness all through this shit. Also for her son.
^_^
I’m confused
Bourbon08
@midnight I was thinking the same thing !!
shiineeeee
dont frickin tell me the duke turned back the time?!
Maple my7h
Interesting,this chapter all she did was reaches,noice 💀👌
Cocoaheart
Disgusting man
attakutti
Damn poor mc her own father is wanting to ruin everything she have.what the fk bastard.
AD.n
can I kill both of them pls ^v^
Nerdzone6
I hope when the MC’s father dies and runs happily to see his wife she slaps him and then says she no longer sees him as her husband for what he did to her daughter.
always reading
That was disgusting 🤮 I feel like I need to wash my hands from touching the screen 📺 YUCK 🤢
Nilar Win
It’s her father?? Wt_-
Still immature and disgusting 🤮
Noir
what is this? the bitch association??
Osonudista
I don’t know how, or since when, but the art has improved! The faces and postures feel more natural and less stiff. It’s so niceee, my eyes are happy :’)
YonaOfTheDawn
I don’t like the old man but I want her to leave her husband (Ya I know it’s not gonna happen this is a shojo story not asoiaf). He should know how it feels to be left alone, isolated like that. Maybe if they get a third chance she can feel sorry for him just like he does now.
An
Dieeeeee fl s father😡😡😡
Anna
What in the actual fuck is this? You hate her to the point of ruining her 1st life and still trying to do the same with her next life just becuz an ACCIDENT. Right, an ACCIDENT that she can not control or wanted in the first place!! You are so disguting !!!
Roco
She’s surrounded by jerks not matter where she goes. It’d be nice if she had at least one close friend on her side
Arshi
THIS FUCKING BITCH I SWEAR IF SHE HURTS ELLE ILL OBLITERATE U THEN STUFF U IN A CONDOM AND THROW U AWAY
Noir
@Arshi why condom?? 🤣
also, dont forget the first step dear, torture the bitch first..
Gojo
I don’t know anymore 😵💫
attakutti
Bitchhhhh if something happens to Elle mc will burn the fkin empire!!! Elle!!! Please be ok.aunt here pray you are ok
Gojo
Haist I wanna slap them with magic stones!
attakutti
Spoiler:-ml’s paternal aunt who is probably king’s mistress have kidnapped elle.king has some brainwashing power and is trying to do that on Elle.undine is trying best to protect elle
Tasya Nabila
I think it’s fair for the duke to hate her, after all she forced her hand onto him even tho he already had a fiancee that he probably loved, I know that the FL probably think that the duke’s the only person who’s kind to her, resulting in her forcing him to marry her but it’s still disgusting… regardless separating a mother from her child is also disgusting, they both have their own fault so maybe they should go separate ways
✨Meh has entered de chat✨
Can’t Reina have at least one friend to stand up for her?
✨Meh has entered de chat✨
@Arshi. Idk why you chose a condom but let me help you torture that bitch!
LenaJay
I feel like I might not be liked for saying this but I don’t think the ml is all that bad like I think he had to have had a good reason for why he treated her like that and I have a big feeling it is because of the fl’s father and that mistress I forgot her name
Corbeau
Honestly, with how unstable Elle’s powers are I almost pity his kidnappers. I mean, just think about what happen to the tableside lamp when he was sleeping. Bitches gonna die by the hands of a toddler.
Tea
Omg the baby 😭
x y z a
Can yall stop judging the ml first. We haven’t seen his side. So I’m neutral for now.
ariana giyu
BULLSHI-
AD.n
UUUUUUUUUUGGGGHHHH I wanna kill them
ViOleT
Im so angry ryt now that i cant keep calm cause of tat white haired bitch👹
Gojo
Where’s elle ugh
Mysterious
Ugh…seriosly trashta shouldn’t leave her relatives around
Mimi
Taina mu pakyu bich go to hell 😡😡😡😡😡😡🤬🤬🤬
Omidee
What’s with that random panel !!!? 🤨
Omidee
No no bruh. Blackjack is the fandom name of 2NE1. It was pretty popular caz both group name and fandom went together
tHe ReTaRd TeEn
i hope she finds elle and hes safe and that bitch of a witch of a whore of a mother and daughter get payback
Omidee
I’m going on a Killing spree just to protect our Elle
Noir
those bastards..
Cissy
Can’t believe they would do that to a poor little baby. I hope they get their butts kicked one way or another.
attakutti
I hope mc gets op and makes a fkin bloodbath at the palace!!! And this bish live quietly huh,you are the one who should live quietly
Tea
Omg breathing same air as her making me puke
Tea
Where my knife WHERE MY KNIFE THAT FUCKING C*** WHITE HAIR WOMEN SHES SOMEONES MOM UR ALSO SOMEONES DAUGHTER KNOW UR OWN PLACE U WHORE
Tea
I SWEAR TO GOD THOSE ASS HOLES DISGUSTED MEE LEGIT
Berryholic
Keep ur disgusting hands off the baby!
ais98ha
I feel like elle went back in time too cause like the part he understood them
Le'Vamuievos
Wish Reina would be able to bring calamity in this wretched empire to show these trashes who they’re messi’n with
Haiji
Cant wait to see that btch dead.
reina simp
I can’t wait for that b***h to die too! And the emperor and the nation to vanish!
ViOleT
PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE AUTHOR PLEASE KILL BOTH THE FUCKING EMPEROR N THE FUCKING UGLY BITCH EMPRESS.OH N ONE IMPORTANT THING TOO PLEASE REMOVE TAT UGLY WHITE HAIRED BITCH PRINCESS FRM OUR TERRITORITY TOO🔪🔪🔪
Thank you~
Saiss
You don’t deserve her😠😠😠😠😠
Roco
I would have already killed the entire Royal family by now 😠. And Reina’s face shows so much emotion now, the artist is getting better
dtizayoi19
bruh, better watch out, heathville got no patience…
Hello kitty
about to punch his bitch of a emperor
Drumy
Does he think he’s gonna survive 10-20 more years 💀
Noir
why do you need to beg?? (unless it’s a tl error) that old bastard and pink btch literally kidnapped your son, at least you should threaten these btches or somthing
Noir
eh wait wrong color lol
*blonde
attakutti
Reina just become powerful and make a bloodbath their girl!!
Jaxin
uhhhh if he really is the male lead he shall be forgiven but never forgotten
Jaxin
even if he changes she will forgive but never foeget
Jaxin
oof my eyesight has always been the worst you know my prediction
Jaxin
UHHHH I THOUGHT THIS WAS A COMPLETED ONE UHHHHHHH
El
I’m crying at 2 a.m lollll, this story— Akhhhhhh
Ruby
I wanna kill them both 🙂🔪
Lilinight
https://discord.gg/MManga
🦇Manhwa Recommendations🦇
yourlostchild
RDICULOUS UTTERLY RIDICULOUS YOUR FIREDDDDD 😄😄😄
Ye, Madam
Repost ㅠㅠ
Shainaid 1992
Oh shit my girl has lost it cause of Elli is sick cause by that darn king’s whore and she has come to seek revenge.
ariana giyu
im confused af
An
Yes mommy destroy all of them and take revenge
ariana giyu
oh👁👄👁
Roco
Bruh I thought she was going to go on a killing rampage staring with her “father”
Drumy
I mean she couldv’e just turned around and left the way she came in but ok
Truck-kun’s little devilish helper
Ngl, She looks like a bitch
c-rosella
There are too many enemies here, it seems that the author is releasing his stress and anger, so it’s like this 🤣🤣🤣it seems like every chapter has many enemies.
Sh
That empress looks like a whore idk :/
Rochelle2009
I hope theres character development in the ml 😭
Rochelle2009
Basically it wasnt the ml’s fault? Its all that sh*tty *ss daddddddddd
Rochelle2009
I officially forgive this duke and accepting him as the ml
Rochelle2009
This a**hole and b*tch needs to die!!!
Rochelle2009
FUCKING BITCH
Rochelle2009
SHE LOOKS LIKE TRASHTA 😭🤺🤺
Rochelle2009
MY BLOOD IS BOILING LIKE A WITCHES CAULDRON THESE MFKERS 🤺🤺🤺
Rochelle2009
Istg i cant wait for them to die
Rochelle2009
Are u the princess? ;-;
lidoxbecky
Uhhh priestess? Prophet? Or god’s messenger? I don’t understand still. Is the temple good or bad at this point? And the duke apparently loved her before the accident too.. it’s too much
Sun
The first time I saw the princess, it reminded me of so many bitches with white hair from so many manhwas that I’ve read
Abby
I feel like her son is the reason why they go back in time… I mean we never know but there’s a possibility that the desire of their son is the reason. There’s also a possibility that their son went back in time just like them… In few chapters you can see that their baby looks like mature the way it act especially when they are in the ship… (sorry for bad English)
scarletulip
what the hell is wrong with this people
ssnseries
Awwwww this is cute man
ssnseries
Oooooh what a rejection 😂
ssnseries
WTF what kind of crazy father is he ??????? 🤮
ssnseries
This guy is a bigger idiot who actually went with all if this…….
ssnseries
I love the kid maaaaan. How amazing. Even if it was a kind of punishment. Genius. He made his father realize all his mistakes with his magic. Relive all of her lonely moments. All his wrong decisions. 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Then whoosh back to past. 🤯👏
The true mvp is the kid here. 👀
I also like how both of them have their memories. This makes things more logical and interesting and easy to sort out. U won’t ever feel like the other one is acting shamelessly…😂 maybe
ssnseries
BTW THAT HOLY FUCK PANEL 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
ssnseries
Now that we know that he has all his memories and that he lived longer than her and knows everything…….. I can’t really forgive him. If reina finds this out too I’m sure she won’t be able to forgive him too.
ssnseries
@arshi 😂🔥🔥🔥 we’re with u
Nia
Eeeeeeeh whaaaaaat???????
Nia
Are u planning to kill the baby ??????? What the helll?!?!?!?!?!?
An
If something happens to the baby im gonna kill him
Hello kitty
Ayo what they doing to the baby why was the table burning red
Ace
Kinda wished it was Cedric😒
Ace
He finally did something right
whendz25
* the father of reina is horrible
* Yes … It is your fault duke… But I’m happy that you know your faults
Ace
Ngl that Rumie guy is hot
Waki
disgusting ass temple with greedy bastards
Manhwafan
Wow Bravo to our strong FL
She is working and handling with pieces of shits in her prego condition
I worship HER
Manhwafan
Here we go, A bitch has appeared
BOBO
NO! NO! PLS BE OKAY PLS PLS PLS. YOUR BABY AND HUBBY NEEDS YOU!!😭😭
Rose
WHO-?
h3ll
Noice 🙂
jjjssslllnnnx
putngna BAKIT NYO BA SILA GUSTO PATAYIN SHUTANGINNERS
h3ll
Yass girl😍
raniveluv
BADASS COUPLE BUT AAA KEEP EL SAFE
Bruhhh
Akoy na bibitin lallalala
Btw thanks for the update
oliviaaamarlen
i hope yall brain don’t get a stroke reading that 😩😖
devilchild35
This is ILLEGAL! Give me MORE!
elmirosalia
Love this manhwa
Dxanii
WHAT 😭😭😭
dtizayoi19
nah, you can’t just end it like that . . . well, as soon as season 2 comes, probably gonna forget the whole story of this
Drumy
I think that’s Elle he’s younger
PLS DONT
NO YOU CANT JUST
AAAAA
Blake
her dad is so dumb how could he blame her when she didn’t even cause the accident you should be grateful she didn’t get hurt but you blamed her bc she’s the only one who doesn’t have an injury like dude get a brain or smth
Blake
@Haiko ikr i really HATE ml’s like that🙄
Blake
They’re rotten af
Blake
sigh when is that man going to die
Blake
geez just get out of her life when are they gonna get a divorce
Blake
🙄😛😂
Blake
nah i still hate him he’s trash even if he’s change and want to fix his mistakes(if he came from the past)it still doesn’t erase the pain he caused her in the past
ssnseries
Who the hell are these peopl? This is too intense
ssnseries
Whooooaaa sooo much happened
ssnseries
Wait whaaaaaatttt aaaaaaaaaah this was like a bomb
GREAT
SCUM!
GREAT
he knows.. he knows.. I KNOW HE KNOWS IT!
GREAT
TRASH! TOTAL TRASH! SOMEONE SEND HIM TO HELL EARLY!
GREAT
so, this is why my guts tells me to ignore the comments on him and wait until the truth is revealed.
tbh, we have the same mindset so i think i would likely will have the same mistake as him,
GREAT
UglyassBitch
GREAT
NOOOOOOOOOOO!!! JUST WHEN I FORGAVE HIM-
Cutsie Girl
That comic at the end☺️💘
LynnTheGreat
HE LOOK SO ADORABLE-
wtvrmrry
😳 omg
TeamWhoeverIs
Aaarrrggghhh!!!! Why blame your daughter for this????
I am fuming because I believe she will be forced into an arranged marriage and then her son not liking her aaaahhhhh!!!!!! I think I need to skip episodes where she is taking her independence >w<
TeamWhoeverIs
Great of course her little brother is an asshole… -_- and since she’s lived with such hostility most of her life; she falls rather quickly to the first guy who showed her human decency…. T^T T^T
TeamWhoeverIs
He took advantage of her loneliness and just used her as an incubator!!!! Girl why choose your kid T^T I know you gave birth to him and couldn’t hold him ‘coz of your trauma and that dickhead took away your son aaaahhhhh!!!! You should have wished for a better life!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Geez Lois!!!! What he’s gonna fall in love with her???!!! What was his reason to checked out from the relationship before eh? She did not give him attention that he needed thus he went to the arms of another???
TeamWhoeverIs
Idiot of a butler…
jjjssslllnnnx
taena nag skip agad 3yrs
TeamWhoeverIs
Say that again you son of a b*tch!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Go Reina and Undine XD XD That’ll show ’em!!
TeamWhoeverIs
I still don’t like the duke X< Ya cheater! Ya abuser just like her dad and brother!
TeamWhoeverIs
Aaawww safe delivery for her and the baby X>
TeamWhoeverIs
Dickhead X< leave the momma and the baby alone!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Why do I feel deja vu??? Oh right Elle is like Jack Jack from The Incredibles XD XD limitless power!! XD XD Super baby!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Go Queen.. I mean Duchess XD XD You are doing great just take a deep breath and take small steps X> We are rooting for you!!
Also, why is the evil side chick here already??!!
TeamWhoeverIs
HHHmmmm,,,, So her change made him not go to his side chick??? -_- I don’t understand but I still don’t like the duke..
TeamWhoeverIs
What about the wind spirit? Save the best for last?
ssnseries
Well he’s gotta regret I guess
Lyry
Finally! Divorce him!
devilchild35
He has his father’s color palate, but even a blind man could see that he is his mother’s son!
devilchild35
I’m so glad her grandfather is on her side, let them bond!
TeamWhoeverIs
I can’t say she’s very cold towards him because on her past future self was mistreated by him… sssoooo….. There is still trauma even if the past has been changed a little…
Ssooo many misunderstandings eh
TeamWhoeverIs
Wait did the duke also came back to the past?? O_O I am so confused
TeamWhoeverIs
That pushover, ignorant, man-child, son of a bitch!!!!
This is so unfair!!!! Her whole life has been nothing but mistreatment aaaiiissshhhh!!!!!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Oh My Glob!!!! The plot thickens!!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Still a coward in my eyes tho… -_- But telling your in-law off was good
TeamWhoeverIs
Damn, that sperm donor and majesty brat makes my blood boil aaahhh!!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Eeeh no wonder the crown prince is like that -_- like father like son.
TeamWhoeverIs
This is so sad T^T T^T I thought we already covered their backstory!!!! My heart can’t take it T^T T^T
TeamWhoeverIs
Aaaiissshhh the duke’s backstory just pisses me off >w< Dude, you treated your wife like the way your mother was treated!!! AArrgghhh!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Aaawww mama Reina is doing everything she can for baby Elle X> how cute!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Those envious bitches >w< that includes the empress as well ugh!
TeamWhoeverIs
Of course that wrench of a woman will work with Reina’s ex-sperm donor…
TeamWhoeverIs
Those freaking maids can’t do no shit!!! Ugh they let the baby go ugh!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
No our dear Undine!!! Where are the others?!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
ugh!! Give back the sweet baby you old power-hungry moron!!!
TeamWhoeverIs
Oh.My.Gosh!!! They can’t catch a break argh!!
TeamWhoeverIs
NNNNOOOO!!!!!
Kiki17
Can you just forgive him please? (>人<)
devon
el is so adorable
shroomiee
u fookin bitch how tf can u blame ur child it’s not like she created the crash go kys u crusty piece of crap excuse of a father
shroomiee
awww poor bby I hope she has a happy life with her child 🙁
shroomiee
I bet he’s going to have some sappy “redemption” story for why he’s such a fucking bastard I hate these kinda cliches theres no fucking reason to treat the fl like crap but it is my guilty pleasure 😞
shroomiee
stfu go away y u acting all simpy now
shroomiee
ye idgaf I don’t feel sorry for this guy call me a notch all u want or wtv atleast he self aware yes it bc of u well done 😍🤗 even after all that why’d u take her child? I hate these cliches where they always make a “acceptable” reason why they can make the fl suffer bc of someone else’s problems well suck it up no one wants ur sob story yes it is all ur fault so leave her alone 😊
shroomiee
well it is the bare minimum… if he didn’t I would’ve pummelled him to the ground istg
shroomiee
I’m sorry but that’s exactly what u did to her history repeats itself even if it was unintentional u made her go through the same experience ur mum went through and u even forgot she was living in ur house thing at some point 💀
shroomiee
yehhhh I’m dropping this I might come back at some point but I just can’t handle this guy being the ml even after his sappy backstory in the synopsis didn’t it say she left him?
shroomiee
ok yk what I’m back I undropped this lol that was fast 💀 I skipped like 20 ch and saw her as the hot badass she is and a hot red guy sooo
Talkie
@TeamWhoeverIs
IM in confusion
Talkie
😳OMG 😳
The_Red_Witch
Repeat of Chapter 38
devon
WHAAAT
Gloss
El you little ball of cuteness 😭
Gloss
Wait whaaaaa
Gloss
Am so confused rn O-O
Gloss
…Just continue working your way you egghard 😑
scrunklypilled
he hasn’t done anything wrong yet lol y’all calm down..
GUESSCHO
OMG I would have never expected that plot twist but I do hope she doesn’t forgive him so it can be his karma
Gloss
Aaaaaaa dont harm the beannnnnnn
Galaxies_bob
Ha want more
Kikiwyu
NOO
devilchild35
Well, I definitely wasn’t expecting that…
devilchild35
Someone’s gonna get hurt, and it’s not El!
aichan
Is it the typical “forced her parents to go somewhere” kinda thing???
Cuz if not it’s the boys “fault” cuz the mother tried to save him.
aichan
No Idt her change is what brought on his change as well.
He already knew something was about to happen during the naming ceremony. This means he probably also has memories of the previous timeline.
Like the typical plot of this trope, something probably happened in the past timeline and he had a realization that he loved her or that he regretted his past neglect of her and is trying to redeem himself in this new life the same way she is trying to change what happened before.
aichan
Yes gurl, you tell him. It’s a little too late for second chances for him.
aichan
Well he’s done everything wrong in the past timeline 🤷🏻♀️ I think it’s justified
aichan
Whatever realization he might have had I wouldn’t have forgiven him if it was me. I’m all for second chances but that’s while I’m STILL ALIVE. But that’s not the case his neglect and indifference contributed to her heartbreak and untimely death.
It doesn’t matter what he does in this new timeline, forgiveness might come his way but it will NEVER BE FORGOTTEN.
aichan
Honestly she’s sometimes smart but also quite stupid. The first thought if someone is acting differently after going back in time is that they’re possibly the same as you.
But she never made such conclusions to this chapter 🤨 the duke may be an asshole but he is a smart asshole he was able to figure it out immediately while she’s still cluelessly walking on eggshells.
aichan
it’s gotten boring 😑 and all her crying and overreacting has gotten toy nerves. Drop.
Athymylove
Bro are you sure he the ml🥲?
Lilyyuichi
Oh god… He actually telling her the past events 🙈 I don’t know how she will react on this
Teacup
uhm is every royal family bat shit crazy???
Teacup
no no is that her son????!! :O
Teacup
ohhhh~ hello
Teacup
ugh sounds like another annoying fly coming into the picture
Teacup
well, that’s just great…
devilchild35
Well, I guess we were already in this hole so might as well keep going…
thingytrace
that is what you call ‘communication well’ telling them the important thing without skipping with thought like ‘it’ll hurt them if I say this’ because that’s just shit, that’s just made it worse. i hope the two can have a good relationship even if it’s not something with love.
devilchild35
The betrayal of having your own mother strike, the agony, HA!
Anotherace
They can’t catch a single break can they
Mangakakalottttttt
Well I would like to see the Duke suffer until he crawl and begged to kill himself or slowly cut his body is tin slices until the Duke can’t scream I want to see him suffer in most cruel way.
Mangakakalottttttt
I hope in the end of this manhua I can see the Duke die
Mangakakalottttttt
Don’t blush ffs you cheated on her and he didn’t even suffer like the duchess he didn’t even died in his past
Mangakakalottttttt
Even if the dukes past is really sad the way he treated his wife is not justified tbh I wish he just died while he was a kid
Kulcipher
I’ll never understand why FLs don’t fight tooth and nail in desperate times like this. You don’t have your powers, okay so BITE. RIP THEIR THROATS OUT.
Manga Karma
@aichan she was not cluelessly walking on eggshells, her focus was simply directed toward her child Elle, and not her so called husband that neglected her
Lilyyuichi
I thought the brother never gonna step up but I proud that he did step up for his sister and deciding to help her.
CatGirlAlena
Thank goodness!
Je ez
Starting this one off with the flimsiest of premises
Je ez
Who the heck is this?
Je ez
These parents and the spirits are useless. As a matter of fact I wonder why bother adding the spirits to the story if the author is going to make them totally ineffective every time they’re needed.
Je ez
So frustrating. They suffered an assassination attempt, had their son kidnapped, walked in on a *second* kidnapping and yet they’re just tooling around with just a few guards and no cares?
Whatdahell -_-
TF now he’s simping?… sus 😑
Whatdahell -_-
Is it wrong that I still don’t feel a shit of pity towards him?
Whatdahell -_-
Bad that I still show no pity? Please someone answer me i need to know!😭
Whatdahell -_-
Is It VeAgAn (MiNuSe A pOiNt) for real but more like “Ya Failed dumbass”
Kyungmin7
@Mangakakalottt, if he died as a kid, there wouldn’t be any Elle
Kyungmin7
Godness this royalties.
And this emperor, he should stop spreading his sperm everywhere, he’s adding more annoying people.
hoosier-daddy
It’s natural for her to think that he is only acting differently because she is acting differently. That is what usually happens in stories like this.
wmdwokxdw
I can’t stop kneeling, I’m addicted to it!!
👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇
http://instantgiphy.com/3002
wmdwokxdw
I can’t stop kneeling, I’m addicted to it!!
👇👇👇👇
http://instantgiphy.com/3002
BellManga
Girllll. I don’t think you know how this work 🤦♀️
Kulcipher
EASILY? HER SON HAS BEEN KIDNAPPED LIKE 3 TIMES
BellManga
I wonder if el actually remembers the past too, his parents
Areti
nah bro istg this father needs to calm tf down
Areti
she gonna slay
Areti
im crying rn 😂😂😂
CatGirlAlena
Those two blonde haired ladies are b****es.
GamingLucy
Wrong story
BellManga
Wrong story :(((
[email protected]
Oh, so the brother wasn’t an ass. I’m glad but dang this dad needs to calm down, how tf did a 7 year old cross you? Like what? Did she destroy the carriage and make the horses go wild? No she did not.
[email protected]
^ dude wtf…you’re weird. Calm down.
[email protected]
Gosh, I never really understood why some of y’all are such bitter b***hes. I really don’t want to say “y’all so bitter and hate yourself so much and that’s why you’re here reading romance novels you clearly hate” but like it’s the truth 😐 y’all sad bitter b***hes.
[email protected]
Bruh, somebody please give them a break!! Their lives are constantly on the line
[email protected]
You see I don’t like the whole divorce thing because WE ALL KNOW THEY ARE GOING TO GET BACK TOGETHER SO SEPARATING THEM FEELS USELESS LIKE I CANT EVEN ROOT FOR HER IN HER SINGLE LIFE CAUSE I KNOW IT AINT GONNA LAST! and yeah that’s all. Thank you for coming to my Ted talk
ssnseries
Uno reverse
Lilyyuichi
Even the spirit hate him 😂
Kulcipher
To be fair Reina always loved El, he was just taken from her in their first life
Diyot
Ok now I understand they both returned to the past.
Diyot
I missed the dad already 🥲
Diyot
El lowkey is a perfect wingman for his dad 🤣
minichu
DUN DUN DUN
Kulcipher
So El is the descendant of both angels and demons, angels through his father’s side and demons from his mother’s
plethora
Is that castle a stock photo or something I swear it’s in every single manhwa
PastelParadox
This is from The Lotto Princess
kokodeez
read the latest Webnovels on “www.fairnovel.com”
PicklebRiNe
idk how to feel about edhart or wtv being the ml,i dont like it
Your grandmother is here
I hate this motherfucker
erikatakeru
i feel bad both of the leads, FL and ML alike, yeah it doesnt justify how he treated his wife. but that’s one hell of a rough childhood, traumatic i must say. its not the least surprising to see how he turned out to be in his first life.
Midnight Reader
What in the world is that jewel on her forehead ,
Midnight Reader
I’m glad the brother was not influenced by the father. He still feel for his sister
Midnight Reader
Hmmmm why a ponytail. I thought she picked a maroon dress